5 Key Questions for Supreme Court in Trump’s Immunity Appeal

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

The court will likely wrestle with separation of powers, the definition of ‘official acts,’ and how curbing immunity could affect executive decision-making.

The Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments on April 25 in President Donald Trump’s appeal arguing that he is immune from criminal prosecution in the case brought by special counsel Jack Smith.

The top court will examine what presidential immunity covers and how it should affect the nation’s separation of powers in future administrations.

Prior cases haven’t definitively established whether presidents enjoy immunity from prosecution over alleged criminal acts. Instead, the court has historically upheld a level of presidential independence and ruled in the 1982 decision of Nixon v. Fitzgerald that a president enjoys absolute immunity from civil liability for acts that fall within the “outer perimeter” of his official duties.

President Trump has argued that immunity should extend to alleged criminal acts. Special counsel Jack Smith and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit were concerned, however, that widening the scope of immunity that far would undermine the separation of powers and allow presidents to get away with egregious wrongdoing.

The circuit court ultimately rejected President Trump’s immunity request in a unanimous decision.

Embedded in these broader debates is a series of questions about the Constitution, its history, and the relationship between the executive and judicial branches. Below are five key questions that have arisen in legal briefs and that the Supreme Court might consider.

1. Part of Official Duties?

The core of Mr. Smith’s prosecution, on behalf of the Department of Justice, rests on President Trump’s activities leading up to and on Jan. 6, 2021, as well as whether his actions constituted attempts to defraud the United States.

More specifically, Mr. Smith’s indictment alleges that President Trump attempted to fraudulently forestall congressional proceedings on Jan. 6, 2021, through the vice president, his advisors, and false electors.

President Trump has denied wrongdoing but also maintained that all of the indicted actions alleged fell within the scope of his official acts, making them immune from prosecution. In his original motion to dismiss, President Trump described his indicted actions as, among other things, part of his duties to ensure election integrity. His motion states that the nature of an act, not President Trump’s motives, should determine whether it’s covered by immunity.

By Sam Dorman

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Armistice and amnesia  

In case you missed it too, June 25th marked the 75th anniversary of the beginning of the Korean War – the first hot front of the Cold War. 

Candace Owens Gets Sued by Macrons

Candace Owens began a deep dive into the lives of French President Emmanuel Macron, his wife Brigitte, and the story of how they came to be together.

Fluoride ‘Tablets’ For Babies EXPLODE in Popularity Amid Water Fluoridation Rollbacks

Reportedly, NPCs are so distraught that their toddlers won’t be fed a neurotoxin through the public water supply that they’ve resorted to fluoride pills.

ChatGPT Goes Biblical about End Times!

There are some truly outstanding internet content creators, or...

Bangkok Indians: ‘You Are Lucky Man’

In Bangkok, friendly prostitutes outside “massage” shops tell me I’m “so handsome man.” Indian men prowling those streets tell me I’m “lucky man.”

Education Department Probe Finds 5 Virginia School Districts Violated Title IX

Five school districts in No. VA violated Title IX by allowing students to access “intimate, sex-segregated facilities based on subjective ‘gender identity,’”

Washington State Sues to Prevent Trump Admin From Accessing Food Aid Immigration Data

Washington state is suing financial services company Fidelity Information Service to prevent it from sharing food aid data with the federal government.

5 Things to Know About Trump Admin’s Settlement With Columbia University

Under agreement between President Trump and Columbia regarding anti-Semitism, school will pay a $200 million fine to regain federal money.

Trumps America: Welp… that backfired.

The official @TheDemocrats account posted chart with the caption “Trump’s America” — but didn’t seem to notice how their own graph actually works.

Ex-DOJ Officials File Lawsuit Against Bondi Over Terminations

Former DOJ officials filed lawsuit against AG Bondi and the fed. govt, saying they were terminated for work on cases related to Jan. 6 Capitol breach.

Odds of U.S.-EU Trade Deal Are 50–50 Ahead of Tariff Deadline: Trump

President Donald Trump said there’s a 50–50 chance that the United States will finalize a trade deal with the European Union before an Aug. 1 deadline.

Trump Pulls Habba’s Nomination for New Jersey’s Top Prosecutor, Making Her Acting US Attorney

President Trump withdrew his nomination of Alina Habba to serve as NJ’s top federal prosecutor, making her Acting US Attorney.

Trump Says He Wants Musk’s Companies to ‘Thrive Like Never Before’

On Thursday, President Trump said, “I want Elon, and all businesses within our Country, to THRIVE, in fact, THRIVE like never before!”
spot_img

Related Articles