The Unconquerable Islamic World

5Mind. The Meme Platform

It never occurred to us that America was what it was because of Christianity, and Afghanistan was what it was because of Islam.

Historians, soldiers and politicians will debate for decades the particulars of what went wrong during America’s intervention in Afghanistan. But a simple truth has been apparent for years: We Westerners failed not for lack of effort, but because military and economic power alone cannot change the Islamic world in a lasting way.

The U.S.-led coalition arrived in South Asia 20 years ago seeking justice after 9/11. Soon we turned into apostles of universal civilization, the idea that human beings everywhere would make the same basic decisions we made in building political community. We set out to establish a liberal democratic state, not realizing that politics lies downstream of culture, and culture downstream of religion. It never occurred to us that America was what it was because of Christianity, and Afghanistan was what it was because of Islam.

The political scientist Samuel Huntington was right: Islamic societies belong to a distinctive civilization that resists the imposition of foreign values through power. We may believe that argument or not, but trillions of dollars, tens of thousands of lives, and two decades of warfare have not proved otherwise.

Still, many remain blind to the obvious. Facing seemingly unrelated chaos in places like Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian territories, Yemen, Libya and Nigeria, our diplomats and strategists devise one-off responses that ignore the common ideologies and actors that link them. Finding piles of broken china around the room, they diligently glue the pieces back together, not seeing the elephant nearby whose feet are covered in ceramic dust.

This blindness is driven by a noble desire to see humans as equal, interchangeable beings for whom faith and culture are accidents of birth. But these accidents are non-negotiable truths for hundreds of millions of people who would rather die than concede them. Failure to comprehend this is a symptom of spiritual emptiness: Alienated from America’s Christian origins, millions cannot fathom how faith could play a vital role in binding humans together.

By Robert Nicholson

Read Full Article on WSJ.com

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Post-Epstein Document Dump: The Moment for Left-Right Populist Unity?

Claims that a powerful, lawless network of child abusers has captured major Western institutions are now asserted with unprecedented certainty.

When care leads to death

On December 12, Illinois legalize physician assisted suicide, rebranded under the soothing sounding banner of “medical aid in dying,” or MAID.

Two Big Game Halftime Show Options

During the Super Bowl this year there will be two halftime shows going on at the same time competing for viewers.

‘Fantasizing About the Caribbean Island’: A Leftist Demigod’s Epic Fall From Grace

I forever washed my hands of Noam Chomsky when he demanded that the unvaccinated be “isolated from society.”

Pride and Prejudice and the Modern Woman: What the Story Should Still Mean to Us Today

Why should Jane Austin's Pride and Prejudice be so influential? Because it upholds biblical precepts pertaining to purity, manhood and womanhood.

‘All-American Halftime Show’ Serves as Alternative to Super Bowl’s Bad Bunny, Green Day Performance

Dueling halftime performances will vie for the attention of viewers across the world at Super Bowl LX in Santa Clara, California, on Sunday night.

Pentagon to Cut Academic Ties With Harvard, Hegseth Says

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth said the Pentagon will cut all academic ties with Harvard, saying the university no longer meets military services needs.

Appeals Court Rejects Challenge to Trump’s Orders Curbing DEI

A federal appeals court turned away a challenge to President Trump’s EO ending so-called DEI programs in the federal government.

Nearly 2,000 Truckers Deemed Unfit Are Removed From American Roads

Nearly 2,000 truckers deemed unqualified to drive on U.S. roads have been removed, with arrests made and many vehicles placed out of service, DOT said.

Why Canada’s China Pivot Makes US Tariff Relief Harder

Analysts say Ottawa’s Beijing outreach is raising new security and trade concerns in Washington—making U.S. tariff relief even harder to secure.

Trump Lifts Biden-Era Restrictions on Commercial Fishing in Atlantic Marine Monument

President Trump revoked a prohibition on commercial fishing in the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument.

US Unveils Interim Trade Framework With India, Drops Punitive Tariff

“The Interim trade framework between the US and India will represent a historic milestone in our countries’ partnership" countries said in a joint statement.

Trump Says He’s Still Looking ‘Seriously’ at Sending $2,000 Tariff Rebate Payments

Trump said in an interview that his administration is still considering sending out $2,000 payments to Americans derived from his tariffs.
spot_img

Related Articles