Did the Iroquois Confederation Influence the Constitution? A Myth They May Be Teaching Your Children

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

Some schools are teaching children that the formation of the American Union, and specifically the Constitution, were influenced heavily by the pre-existing federation of the Iroquois Indians. There are many websites making the same claim.

As someone with native ancestry, Iโ€™d be glad if it were true. But itโ€™s demonstrably false. Parents who find out that their children are being fed this misinformation should insist that it be stopped. Parents may provide school administrators with this essay for support.

The Iroquois Great Law of Peace

The Iroquois were based in New York State. They consisted initially of five groups. The Europeans and American colonists called these groups โ€œtribes,โ€ โ€œcantons,โ€ or โ€œnations.โ€

The โ€œGreat Law of Peaceโ€ was the constitution of the Iroquois Confederation (pdf). It may have been adopted as early as the 12th century or as late as the 17th. In either case, it was older than the United States. In 1722, the Tuscarora people joined the confederation, thereby expanding it from five tribes to six. During the American Founding Era, the Iroquois Confederation was often referred to as the Six Nations.

The Great Law and the Iroquois Confederation were outstanding achievements, worthy of historical recognition and study. As we shall see, however, they didnโ€™t have an appreciable influence on the American Union or on the Constitution.

Was Benjamin Franklin Influenced?

Those who assert that the Iroquois Confederation influenced the Constitution rely heavily on the career of Benjamin Franklin. They note that Franklinโ€™s printing company reproduced a 1744 speech by an Iroquois leader urging union among the American colonies. They also point to a 1751 letter from Franklin stating that if the Iroquois could unite, the colonies could, too. They say that Franklin โ€œreferencedโ€ the Iroquois Confederation when proposing his own โ€œPlan of Unionโ€ at an inter-colonial convention in 1754.

In fact, however, none of those events suggest that Franklin considered the Iroquois Confederation to be a model for an American constitution. Hereโ€™s why:

First, Franklinโ€™s print shop reproduced the 1744 โ€œunity speechโ€ only because it was printing a volume collecting 13 negotiations leading to Indian treaties, and the speech happened to be in the records for one of the 13. The speech occupied only 10 lines in the 450-page volume.

Franklinโ€™s 1751 letter mentioned unity, but contained no discussion of the institutions of the Iroquois or whether the colonies might copy them.

The 1754 document apparently was not even written by Franklin, but by Thomas Hutchinson. Hutchinson played no role in the crafting of the American Constitution; he was a Tory who fled to England during the Revolution. Moreover, the document touched mostly on colonial-Indian relations, not on the Iroquois form of government.

Even if these events were reliable indices of Franklinโ€™s personal opinions, they would tell us little about influences on the other 54 framers decades later. They would tell us still less about the views of the 1648 state convention delegates who ratified the Constitution or of the public who elected those delegates.

By Rob Natelson

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Common Sense Economics and Finance: Value Established for the American Republic

A infection has mutated federal finance into a condition of political inflation, and valueless FED money is proof that the Federal Reserve is the root cause of that condition.

Pastor Corey Brooks is Walking Across America!

Last night I got to fulfill a bucket list item. I got to meet one of my personal heroes of our time (after Donald Trump) Pastor Corey Brooks.

Is Japan About to Be Gifted With Our Greatest Strengthโ„ข?

Japan sees little resistance to new immigrants, but policies provide inadequate support to integrate them into Japanese economy and society.

Cracker Barrelโ€™s Remake Proves Lefty Women Unfit to Lead

โ€œThe customer is always rightโ€ remains true today regardless of whether people like Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Masino opt to respect it and follow it or not.

Walmart on Its Radioactive Shrimp: โ€˜The Health and Safety of Our Customers Is Always a Top Priority’

โ€œNowadays people know the price of everything and the...

California Parole Board Denies Parole for Erik Menendez

CA Board of Parole Hearings rejected the release of Erik Menendez, one of the two brothers convicted in the 1989 killing of their parents in Southern CA.

Intel Has Agreed to Give US Government 10 Percent Stake: Trump

The White House had been seeking an equity stake in the company in exchange for the almost $11 billion in grants from the CHIPS and Science Act.

FBI Searches Home of Former National Security Adviser John Bolton: Reports

FBI searched Maryland home of John Bolton, former national security adviser under President Trump, as part of a classified documents investigation.

5 Takeaways From Fed Chair Powellโ€™s Final Jackson Hole Speech

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell presented his final keynote address at the central bankโ€™s annual Jackson Hole summit on Aug. 22.

Trumpโ€™s Tariffs Will Reduce Deficits by $4 Trillion Over Next Decade, Says CBO Report

A report released by the CBO predicted that President Donald Trumpโ€™s tariffs will reduce federal deficits by around $4 trillion over the next decade.

USDA Issues Memorandum Prioritizing American Energy on National Forest Lands

Secretary Rollins said that the United States will no longer allow foreign-made solar panels or inefficient energy projects to undermine national security.

US Pauses Visas for Commercial Truck Drivers, Citing Safety and Other Impacts

The Trump administration will immediately pause the issuance of all worker visas for commercial truck drivers, Sec of State Marco Rubio said.

Chip Stocks Fall on Reports White House Seeking Equity in Exchange for Grants

Share prices of semiconductor companies fell following reports the Trump admin is considering taking equity stakes in exchange for federal funding.
spot_img

Related Articles