Are Americans turning isolationist?

Contact Your Elected Officials

The โ€œAmerica Firstโ€ foreign policy approach, much touted by many Republicans, is characterized by prioritizing national interests, economic nationalism, and a skeptical stance on international agreements and alliances.

On the positive side, this approach can lead to greater focus on domestic issues, potentially driving policy decisions that aim to bolster national security, economic growth, and job creation within the United States. By adopting a stance that prioritizes American interests, the approach seeks to ensure that trade agreements, military engagements, and international partnerships are directly beneficial to the U.S., possibly leading to renegotiated deals perceived as more favorable.

This approach also emphasizes national sovereignty, aiming to reduce dependency on other countries and international bodies, which can be seen as enhancing the countryโ€™s ability to make independent decisions.

However, this approach carries significant drawbacks and while Republicans support it, many Democrats are concerned that it does not mesh with their worldview. Isolationism is likely to strain long-standing alliances and partnerships, as it often involves a reassessment of the terms of engagement that may not always align with the interests or expectations of allies. On the security front, skepticism towards multinational agreements and organizations could undermine collaborative efforts to address global challenges, which Democrats say require collective action.

James Lindsay noted recently in his Council on Foreign Relations blog that the Chicago Council on Global Affairs has been asking Americans for several decades: โ€œDo you think it will be best for the future of the country if we take an active part in world affairs or if we stay out of world affairs?โ€

In the most recent survey, 57 percent of respondents opted for playing an active role. In contrast, 42 percent favored staying out of world affairs.

A recent Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research found a similar public tilt toward internationalism. In their poll, 23 percent wanted the U.S. to take a more active role in solving world problems, and 36 percent said that the current
level of U.S. involvement is about right. In contrast, just 40 percent wanted the U.S. to be less active.

Chicago Council polls found that the American public favors internationalism rather than isolationism. In addition, a Gallup poll in February found that two out of three Americans want the U.S. to keep or increase its commitment to NATO.

However, these polls notwithstanding, Harvard professor Joseph S. Nye, Jr. has argued that Trumpโ€™s election in 2016 represented a clear shift away from the liberal tradition.

Polls show that many Republicans are divided, raising concerns that if an isolationist Republican wins in 2024, it could mark a turning point for the US-dominated international order established at the end of World War II.

As Nye notes, historically, โ€œAmerican public opinion has oscillated between extroversion and retrenchment.โ€

Nye pointed to history.

โ€œHaving witnessed the tragic consequences of the isolationism of the 1930s, President Franklin D. Roosevelt launched the process that culminated in the creation of the Bretton Woods institutions in 1944 and the United Nations in 1945. President Harry Trumanโ€™s post-war decisions then led to permanent alliances and a continual US military presence abroad,โ€ he wrote. โ€œThe United States invested heavily in European reconstruction through the Marshall Plan in 1948, created NATO in 1949, and led the UN coalition that fought in Korea in 1950.โ€

NBC reporter Dan De Luce explained that in 1940, as Hitlerโ€™s troops rolled across Europe, many Republicans argued against sending American weapons to Britain.

They argued that the government should put โ€œAmerica First.โ€

Now, De Luce says, โ€œformer President Donald Trump and his allies in Congress use the same slogan to make similar arguments against sending military aid to another democratic country in Europe under assault by a powerful authoritarian regime.โ€

But there is a reason for this.

The Republican Party exhibits a split in foreign policy, with one faction advocating for aggressive, unilateral engagement and another pushing for a more isolated stance to focus on internal challenges and specific geopolitical rivals like China. This divide reflects broader debates within the party on how to approach global issues, from supporting Ukraine against Russia to dealing with China and immigration policies.

The differences highlight a range of strategies from traditional internationalism to more isolationist approaches, influenced by figures like Trump and manifested in varying positions on different foreign policy issues.

Many Republicans thus believe that American isolationism would offer several benefits, including prioritizing domestic issues over international ones, reducing the likelihood of becoming entangled in foreign wars, and potentially fostering a greater sense of national unity and self-sufficiency. Such a foreign policy school of thought and action would help America to focus on its own economic and social
challenges, preserving resources that might otherwise be spent on overseas commitments.

For Republicans, the elections in November will partially be about which foreign policy approach the U.S. will follow for the next four years. Will voters choose the Democrat way of liberal internationalism? Or will voters choose the Republican ideal of America firstโ€?

In essence, the “America First” policy approach embodies a tension between the pursuit of immediate national interests and the benefits derived from global cooperation and engagement.

Emily Thompson
Emily Thompson
Emily Thompson is an analyst on U.S. domestic and foreign affairs. Her work appears in various news publications including on the Activist Post, on The Published Reporter and here on TheThinkingConservative.com.

Coldplay Concert Offers Us Garden of Eden Moment

Adultery is still illegal in 10 states. It was illegal in 15 states just 30 years ago. There was a time when adultery was a crime in all 50 states!

Uncle SLICโ€™s lingering loans

School may be out for the summer, but the Student Loan Industrial Complex (SLIC) chugs along no matter what time of the year it is.

Epsteinโ€™s Island

The miscommunication by Trump Admin officials on Epstein rival any of the comedic exchanges between the Skipper and Gilligan, without the laughs.

Why Thinking Americans Are Pissed!

Some people in this country do not think much...

Rise by the Conspiracy Theory, Fall by the Conspiracy Theory

The uproar in the MAGA world over the failure to release the Jeffrey Epstein client list should be a cause for serious concern for President Trump.

Ole Miss Football Player Corey Adams Killed in Tennessee Shooting

Ole Miss freshman football player Corey Adams was killed in a shooting in Tennessee, the Shelby County Sheriffโ€™s Office announced Sunday.

Texas AG Sues Masters Swimming Group That Allowed Transgender Athletes

Texas AG Ken Paxton sued an adult swimming organization after it allowed transgender athletes to compete at a womenโ€™s spring meet in San Antonio.

American Express Hits Record Revenue as Card Member Spending Surges

American Express generated record second-quarter revenue amid strong spending by cardholders, the company said in a July 18 statement.

Missing Persons in Texas County Floods Revised to 3 From 160

Texas officials said Saturday that most of the 160 people reported missing in Kerr County have been accounted for, but that three are still missing.

Commerce Secretary Says US Still Eyeing 10 Percent Baseline Tariff

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said the US is still aiming to leave a 10 percent baseline tariff on many smaller countries

Trump Signs Order to Reclassify Noncareer Federal Workers

President Trump signed an EO to create a new classification of noncareer federal workers whose roles are focused on implementing presidentโ€™s policy agenda.

Trump Pledges to Prevent US Central Bank Digital Currency

CBDC will not be allowed in the Us, President Trump said at a White House event, promising to take legislative action to prevent such a situation.

EPA Slashes 23 Percent of Its Workforce, Eliminating Scientific Research Arm

EPA announced it will cut about 23% of its workforce and eliminate its research and development office as part of the agencyโ€™s restructuring effort.
spot_img

Related Articles