Court Rejects Bid to Throw Out Trump Case Against Pulitzer Board

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

Judgeโ€™s ruling means defamation case is moving forward.

A court in Florida has rejected a bid from members of the Pulitzer Prize Board to throw out a case brought against them by former President Donald Trump.

The boardโ€™s statement in 2022 standing behind its awards to several news outlets for reporting on former President Trumpโ€™s purported links to Russia is actionable because it is not merely opinion, Florida Circuit Court Judge Robert Pegg ruled on July 20.

Defendants withheld valuable information from readers, including the process by which complaints against the awards were evaluated, according to the judge.

In the July 18, 2022, statement, the board said that it โ€œcarefully reviewedโ€ complaints against the awards, which were given in 2018 to The New York Times and The Washington Post.

โ€œBoth reviews were conducted by individuals with no connection to the institutions whose work was under examination, nor any connection to each other,โ€ the board said at the time. โ€œThe separate reviews converged in their conclusions: that no passages or headlines, contentions or assertions in any of the winning submissions were discredited by facts that emerged subsequent to the conferral of the prizes.โ€

The brief statement, though, was not pure opinion because the board failed to identify any of the reviewers, reveal whether the reviewers had any connection to the board, and share the reviewersโ€™ qualifications, Judge Pegg said.

โ€œIf the defendantsโ€™ statement had included the foregoing facts, an ordinary reader might have been able to evaluate whether they agreed with defendantsโ€™ decision not to revoke the prizes, and whether the underlying reporting had actually survived the factual disclosures of several subsequent government investigations unscathed,โ€ the judge wrote. โ€œInstead, the alleged defamatory statement implies no fewer than seven undisclosed sets of foundational facts, making the defendantsโ€™ statement actionable mixed opinion.โ€

Under Florida law, people cannot sue over pure opinion.

The board did not respond to a request for comment.

Byย Zachary Stieber

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Sweeney Swoon

Sydney Sweeney donned American Eagle jeans and hawked them as part the "Sydney's got great jeans" campaign, and the Left acted like she'd committed an atrocity.

Lay Democrats to Waste, Post Truths in Copy and Paste!

Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) humorously stated, โ€œOur secret plan for dealing with the Democrats is called, โ€˜Operation: Let them speak.โ€™โ€

Congress doesnโ€™t Care What the Average Person Thinks

In researching voting rights issues, a study provides a foundation for the statement โ€œgovernment officials donโ€™t care what people like them think.โ€

Domestic Terrorists Rain Adult Toys on WNBA Courts in Multiple Aerial Assaults

In what might be described as the worst terrorist attack on American soil since 9/11, multiple WNBA courts have been pelted with brutal flying missiles.

Democrats Are In Disastrous Shape As Midterms Loom

According to CNN's Harry Enten, โ€œThe Democratic brand is in the basement. It is total and complete garbage in the mind of the American public.โ€

What to Know About Texasโ€™s Redistricting Showdown

TX Democrats defied Gov. Abbottโ€™s call to return to state for a hearing on redrawing Congressional lines, setting up a showdown between the two sides.

Texas House Votes to Arrest Democratic Lawmakers Who Left State

TX House of Reps voted 85โ€“6 to arrest Democrat lawmakers who werenโ€™t present when House went into session, due to fight over congressional districts.

Agriculture Secretary Clears 6 More States to Ban Purchasing Soda With Food Stamps

Ag. Sec. Rollins signed waivers filed by Colorado and five other states allowing them to ban use of food stamps to buy soda and other sugary drinks.

Harley-Davidson Names Topgolf Chief Artie Starrs as New CEO

Harley-Davidson named Artie Starrs, chief executive of Topgolf, as its new president and CEO, as motorcycle maker seeks to reinvigorate growth.

Trump Vows to โ€˜Substantially Raise Tariffโ€™ on India Over Russian Oil Imports

Trump said he would โ€œsubstantiallyโ€ raise tariffs on goods from India, citing countryโ€™s continued purchase of Russian oil despite his demand that it stop.

European Union Suspends US Tariff Countermeasures for 6 Months

The EU will suspend its two packages of countermeasures to U.S. tariffs for six months, a European Commission spokesman said on Monday.

Trump Says Americans Could Get Dividends From Tariff Revenues

President Donald Trump suggested on Sunday that his administration could distribute dividends from tariff revenues to Americans with certain income levels.

Tariff Rates โ€˜Pretty Much Set,โ€™ Says US Trade Representative

President Trumpโ€™s trade representative, Jamieson Greer, said that Americans should expect the administrationโ€™s tariff levels to remain where they are.
spot_img

Related Articles