Dangerous Ramifications of Reshuffled Iran Nuclear Deal

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Heritage Foundation Header

Key Takeaways

  1. An agreement could be announced as soon as next week and is sure to be lauded as a diplomatic triumph by the Biden White House.
  2. Tehran will pocket billions of dollars in sanctions relief to finance its hostile policy agenda.
  3. The biggest beneficiaries of a renewed nuclear deal would be China and Russia. The biggest losers would be the U.S., its allies, and the Iranian people.

After being derailed in early March by Russiaโ€™s demand for protection against U.S. sanctions, the negotiations over Iranโ€™s nuclear program are set to resume soon in Vienna, after Iranโ€™s Nowruz holiday, a celebration of the Persian new year, which started Monday.

Although the negotiations are approaching the finish line, specific details about what already has been agreed to have not been divulged by the Biden administration. A State Department spokesman said on Monday that an agreement is โ€œneither imminent nor certain.โ€

Iranian Foreign Minister Hossein Amirabdollahian said on Wednesday, โ€œWe believe that today we are closer to an agreement in Vienna than ever before.โ€ But he warned: โ€œWe reminded the Americans that we will not cross our red lines.โ€

Amirabdollahian likely was referring to two key issues that reportedly remain to be resolved: Tehranโ€™s demand that its Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps be granted immunity from U.S. sanctions imposed on foreign terrorist organizations and its insistence on receiving a guarantee that the U.S. will not withdraw from the agreement, as President Donald Trump did in 2018.

Windfall for Revolutionary Guards

The Revolutionary Guards have become a major stumbling block of the negotiations because they represent many aspects of why Iran was sanctioned in the first place. Not only do they control vital portions of Iranโ€™s covert nuclear weapons efforts, but they also control Iranโ€™s ballistic missiles, orchestrate Iranโ€™s proxy terrorist network, serve as the regimeโ€™s repressive Praetorian Guard, and dominate important sectors of Iranโ€™s economy.

U.S. sanctions on the Revolutionary Guards are a necessary punitive action that drains their access to funds from their front companies and deters future terrorist attacks. 

If the sanctions on the Revolutionary Guards were lifted, the regime in Tehran will pocket more benefits from a new agreement than under the original deal, which did not include lifting nonnuclear sanctions. Moreover, the Revolutionary Guards will gain enormous economic benefits that they surely will use to finance malign activities.

An agreement could be announced as soon as next week and is sure to be lauded as a diplomatic triumph by the Biden White House.

But the deputy special envoy for Iran and two other diplomats who resigned from the U.S. negotiating team because they were alarmed by the scale of U.S. concessions at the talks have strong reasons to disagree with that spin.

The Biden administration appears to be on the verge of negotiating a weaker, shorter, and more risky deal with Iran than the Obama administration did in 2015.

Kicking Nuclear Can Down Road

Another flawed nuclear agreement with Iran will at best postpone the time of reckoning while a hostile and vengeful regime recovers from sanctions, builds up its ballistic missile arsenal, and exports terrorism to intimidate its regional adversaries and drive the U.S. out of the Middle East.

Although the Biden White House is sure to claim that an agreement puts Iranโ€™s nuclear program โ€œback in a box,โ€ the walls of that box will become increasingly weak as the most restrictive provisions of the deal are scheduled to sunset. After those restrictions sunset, the agreement is likely to die in darkness.

Iran, allowed to build an industrial-scale uranium enrichment program, will be put on a glide path to a nuclear breakout or a covert โ€œsneak-out.โ€

A revived nuclear deal would allow Tehran to trade short-term restrictions on its nuclear program that it could easily renege on, as it has many times before, in return for long-term sanctions relief.  But this sanctions relief for Iran would not bring relief from Iranโ€™s proxy attacks.

In fact, the resurrection of the flawed 2015 agreement would not defuse tensions in the Middle East, but would fuel them. Iranโ€™s aggressive dictatorship would become emboldened and empowered to escalate its intimidation tactics against its regional adversaries, as it did after the 2015 deal.

Tehran will pocket billions of dollars in sanctions relief to finance its hostile policy agenda. In effect, U.S. concessions on sanctions would subsidize Iranโ€™s military buildup, expansion of its proxy terrorist network, and even Iranโ€™s nuclear program.

Dismayed by a deal that would strengthen Iranโ€™s Islamist dictatorship, countries threatened by Iran would hedge their security bets and seek insurance by improving ties to China and Russia for protection.  Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates already have taken steps in this direction.

China and Russia also would reap huge economic, strategic, and foreign policy benefits under the deal, which would remove barriers to closer relations with Tehran. Moscow, in addition to receiving immunity from U.S. nuclear sanctions, also would gain a huge customer for its arms, flush with cash due to sanctions relief.

China, which last year signed a 25-year, $400 billion strategic partnership with Iran, will gain easier access to a major source of oil imports, increased trade, and a reinvigorated ally in a vital oil-rich region.

Israel will be forced to take unilateral action, covertly or overtly, to delay Iranโ€™s nuclear progress. That will lead to the intensification of the shadow war instigated by Iran against Israel, waged with new vigor by Iranโ€™s Revolutionary Guards and their proxies in Gaza, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, and Yemen.

To make matters worse, while Iran may become more aggressive, the Biden administration may become even more passive, fearful that a strong pushback against Iranโ€™s destabilizing regional activities would jeopardize the illusory triumph of the vaunted nuclear deal.

Biggest Winners, Losers

The Biden administrationโ€™s complacent accommodation of a fiercely hostile Iranian regime is likely to yield a half-baked agreement that will only postpone a festering nuclear crisis, not resolve it.  

Another flawed agreement would kick the can down the road while flooding Iran with sanctions relief that will embolden the regime, accelerate its military buildup, and strengthen its proxy terrorist networks for future attacks. 

As noted above, in addition to Iran, the biggest beneficiaries of a renewed nuclear deal would be China and Russia.

The biggest losers would be the U.S., its allies, and the Iranian people, who would be condemned to live under the repression of a bolstered regime.

By James Phillips
Senior Research Fellow, The Heritage Foundation

Read Original Article on Heritage.org

About James Phillips

James Phillips is a senior research fellow for Middle Eastern affairs at The Heritage Foundation.

The Heritage Foundation
The Heritage Foundationhttps://www.heritage.org/
The Heritage Foundation formulates and promotes public policies based on free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional values, and strong national defense.

Transitioning from Regulatory Sclerosis to Arbitrary State Capitalism

The Trump administration is moving from reducing the size and regulatory power of the federal government to the formation of State Capitalism.

Gen Z and Crystallized Intelligence

Weโ€™ve created a new malaise: media fatigue and information overload, or โ€œdata smog,โ€ which has sharply accelerated in recent years.

Meet the Fairy From Hell in Charge of Vaccines at CDC Until Last Week

Picture the creepiest leather-daddy gimp at your local Prideโ„ข festival. Thatโ€™s this guy, Demetre Daskalakis, who ran the entire federal govt vaccine program.

The Clinton-Epstein Connection We Did Not Know

One attorney's inside info about D.C. and the relationship the Clintonโ€™s had with the late child sex pedophile Jeffrey Epstein

Faith under fire

Over half of historyโ€™s 70M Christian martyrs were killed in the 20th century, amid totalitarian regimes, purges, and ethnic violence.

Grand Jury Declines to Indict Woman Who Threatened Trump

A grand jury has declined to indict a woman who threatened President Donald Trump on social media, her lawyers said on Sept. 1.

Trump Admin Violated Law With Troop Deployment in LA, Judge Rules

A federal judge in California has ruled that the Trump administration unlawfully used Marines and National Guard troops in Los Angeles.

Kentucky Ends In-State College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants After DOJ Lawsuit

Kentucky agreed to end a policy that had allowed illegal immigrants to access in-state college tuition rates, following a lawsuit by the DOJ.

Gold Hits All-Time High Amid Rate Cut Expectations

Gold prices hit an all-time high on Tuesday amid expectations of an interest rate cut and growing uncertainty related to tariffs.

Trump Takes Aim at Crime in Chicago After Dozens Shot Over Weekend

President Trump said that he will โ€œsoonโ€ take actions to deal with crime in Chicago, weeks after he sent National Guard troops to Washington, D.C.

Trump Says India Offered Zero Tariffs After Decades of โ€˜One-Sidedโ€™ Trade

President Trump said India offered to cut tariffs on U.S. goods to zero, calling it a long-overdue fix for decades of one-sided trade.

Trump Says He Will Issue Executive Order to Require Voter ID

โ€œVoter I.D. Must Be Part of Every Single Vote. No exceptions!โ€ Trump wrote on a post on Truth Social. โ€œI Will Be Doing An Executive Order To That End!!!โ€

Appeals Court Rules Most of Trumpโ€™s Tariffs Are Illegal

The judges let the import taxes stay in place...
spot_img

Related Articles