Dr. John Clauser: “Climate Change is NOT a Crisis”

Contact Your Elected Officials
Brownstone Institute

CO2 Coalition Board of Directors member and Nobel laureate, Dr. John Clauser gave these remarks at Quantum Korea 2023 Seoul.

Dr. John F. Clauser, born 1942, is an American theoretical and experimental physicist known for contributions to the foundations of quantum mechanics. Clauser was awarded the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, jointly with Alain Aspect and Anton Zeilinger โ€œfor experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell inequalities and pioneering quantum information science.โ€

Transcript

Oh, I hope there wasnโ€™t a significant miscommunication in the invitation for this particular talk, Iโ€™m going to give it another one later on โ€“ the keynote address. I was asked for the first to make some brief remarks as inspiration to young Korean scientists. Iโ€™m not sure, wasnโ€™t sure how to do that, so hereโ€™s my best shot at it and it really has very little to do with quantum technology, but here are my inspirational thoughts.

A long time ago, actually my whole life, I have been an experimental physicist. Have had the distinct privilege of literally being able to talk to God even though Iโ€™m an atheist. In a physics laboratory, I am able to ask carefully posed mathematically-based questions and correspondingly observe universal truth.

To do so I make careful measurements of natural phenomena. In the physics laboratory, I once settled the debate between Einstein and Schrodinger on one hand, Niels Bohr and John von Neumann on the other. In a laboratory, I asked a simple question: which one of these two groups was right? And which one was wrong?

I didnโ€™t know ahead of time what answer I would get. I just knew I could get an answer. Nonetheless, I found real truth. For the answer. I assert that real truth can only be found by observing natural phenomena. By carefully observing natural phenomena.

Good science is always based on good experiments. Good observations always overrule purely speculative theory. Sloppy experiments, on the other hand, are frequently counterproductive and provide scientific disinformation. That is why good scientists repeat each otherโ€™s experiments carefully.

For inspiration to young scientists, I would suggest that today is an opportune moment for careful observations of nature. Why? The current world I observe is literally awash, saturated, with pseudoscience, with bad science, with scientific misinformation and disinformation, and what I will call โ€techno-cons.โ€ Techno-cons are the application of scientific disinformation for opportunistic purposes.

Non-science business managers, politicians, politically appointed lab directors and the like are very easily snowed by scientific disinformation. Sometimes they participate in its origination. The purpose is to try to inspire you as young scientists to observe nature directly so that you too can determine real truth. Use the information gained from carefully performed experiments and research to stop the spread of scientific misinformation, disinformation and techno-cons.

Well-educated scientists can help solve the worldโ€™s problems by acting as scientific fact-checkers. A fact-checkerโ€™s most common problem, unfortunately, is determining what is true and what is not. The world is awash with someone elseโ€™s perception of truth as an alternative to real truth.

Perception of truth frequently differs significantly from real truth. Moreover, given sufficient promotion and advertising, perception of truth becomes truth. Its promotion by commercial enterprise Is called marketing, commonly used in the furtherance of political, commercial, or various opportunistic ends by its promoters. When promotion is done by government or political groups, itโ€™s called spin or propaganda.

To such a promoter, perception of truth is truth. If you can sell it, it must be true. If you canโ€™t sell it, it must be false. Perception of truth is also malleable. If you can sell it, if you want to sell it, and you canโ€™t sell it, thatโ€™s easy. You change it. You can change truth. You can claim false observations if necessary.

My favorite in this act is ChatGPT. Itโ€™s very good at doing exactly that. It has lots of man-made pseudoscience to copy and manipulate and emulate. It can lie and cheat even better than its human mentors whose writings are abundant in literature. In literature, you will observe thereโ€™s far more fiction than there is nonfiction. Pseudoscience is science fiction. Unfortunately, neither computers nor human fact-checkers can, in general, tell fact from fiction. Or science from science fiction or from pseudoscience.

If Starship Enterprise can fly faster than the speed of light, itโ€™s gotta be possible, right? All you need is dilithium crystals, right? Wrong.

Real truth is not malleable. It can only be found by making careful observations. Well-tested laws of physics and observational data are important guides to allow you to distinguish truth from perception of truth.

Now I am not alone in observing the dangerous proliferation of pseudoscience. Recently, The Nobel Foundation has formed a new panel to address the issue called the International Panel on Information Environment. They plan to model it after the UNโ€™s International Panel on Climate Change, the IPCC.

I think personally that they are making a big mistake in that effort because in my opinion the IPCC is one of the worst sources of dangerous misinformation. What Iโ€™m about to recommend is in furtherance of that, of the aims of that panel.

In the past, we scientists act, have acted, as referees for journal article peer review. And we have peer-reviewed each otherโ€™s work, so as just to prevent the proliferation of scientific misinformation. That process recently seems to have broken down. Somehow it needs to be reenergized.

During my career as a scientist, I have frequently been asked to referee lots of scientific journal articles. Here I will offer a few pieces of advice. First, very importantly, your work should be based on careful observations of nature. You must try hard and recognize what I will call an elephant in the room hiding in plain sight. Ask very simple questions. I found an elephant in the room that I will be describing in my keynote address in quantum mechanics.

I have a second elephant in the room that I have recently discovered regarding climate change. I believe that climate change is not a crisis.

Real truth could be found if and only if you learn to recognize and use good science. Itโ€™s especially true when real truth is politically incorrect and does not reflect political, business aims, or desires of leaders. Even the scientific community can sometimes become diluted by pseudoscience.

Recall, if you want pseudoscience to be true, just simply spin it and it becomes true. Importantly, a referee must know and use mathematically based physics. A good scientist must also know how to derive and solve differential equations. That was the first thing I learned as an undergraduate at Caltech.

Follow the teaching of Sir Isaac Newton. He found that the world is governed by differential equations. He had to invent calculus to do it, but he did it. A referee must correctly identify the dominant processes. Thatโ€™s the starting point. The best way to do this is with order of magnitude estimates of the various conceivable processes.

One of my examples I can give later, I donโ€™t have time to do it though regarding climate change, the dominant process I believe, has been misidentified by factors of 200. So, if youโ€™re off by a factor of one hundred, two hundred, your process is way too small to be important. Itโ€™s the big one โ€“ big numbers matter, little numbers can be neglected.

Sometimes people will promote new ideas that are off by factors of a million. They just simply havenโ€™t run the numbers themselves. The most pathetic part of all this is that they donโ€™t know that they need to know how to do that. Their lack of scientific knowledge allows science, pseudoscience, to promote what I will refer to as techno-cons, political opportunistic aims.

Techo-cons are readily unmasked and identified if you simply apply order of magnitude calculations. Very importantly, a referee must apply good calculus-based statistical methods along with good common sense. I would also like you to consider methods used by two of my former associates at University of California, Berkeley, Nobel laureates. When they were shown data, a group of data points and told โ€œLook, the trend is obvious,โ€ Luis Alvarez, Nobel laureate, would look at it and say, โ€œFlattest line I ever saw.โ€ Charlie Townes would look at it and say, โ€œI donโ€™t see in the data what youโ€™re telling me Iโ€™m supposed to see.โ€

Beware. If youโ€™re doing good science, it may lead you into politically incorrect areas. If youโ€™re a good scientist, you will follow them. I have several I wonโ€™t have time to discuss, but I can confidently say there is no real climate crisis, and that climate change does not cause extreme weather events.

Transcript of Dr. John Clauserโ€™s address at Quantum Korea 2023 from Brownstone Institute.

Note: Dr. Clauser speech at Quantum Korea 2023 prompted the International Monetary Fund to cancel his appearance and began a predictable trajectory of broader cancellation.

Brownstone Institute
Brownstone Institutehttps://brownstone.org/
The Brownstone Institute for Social and Economic Research is a nonprofit organization conceptualized in May 2021. Its vision is of a society that places the highest value on the voluntary interaction of individuals and groups while minimizing the use of violence and force even including that which is exercised by public authority.

Liberal Democrat Content Creators are Despicable Defamationers

What should Christian conservatives do when confronted with false information to the point of bearing false witness against someone like President Trump?

Ben Shapiro Warning Me Not to Listen to InfoWars Makes Me Want to Listen 10x Harder

This rant from Ben Shapiro reveals more about him and his low opinion of his audience to whom he peddles his slop than it does about its target, Alex Jones.

Epsteinโ€™s Aftermath: Planes, Blames, and Autocrats

There are so many real, honest great journalists reporting the news on the internet these days that some really good content gets overlooked.

Why the Trump Administration is Sitting on the Epstein Files

President Trump, AG Bondi, and FBI Dir. Patel have the advantage over us in that they see the big overall picture when it comes to the Epstein List.

Trumpโ€™s โ€œMajor Statementโ€ On Russia Is A Clumsy Attempt To Thread The Needle

The โ€œmajor statementโ€ on Russia Trump hyped up turned out to be an attempt to thread the needle between escalating US involvement in Ukrainian and walking away from it.

7.3 Magnitude Earthquake Hits Off Alaska Coast; Tsunami Warning Issued

A 7.3-magnitude earthquake struck off the coast of southern Alaska prompting federal officials to issue a tsunami warning.

University of Southern California Faces $300 Million in Federal Funding Cuts, Staff Layoffs

USC faces potential revenue loss of hundreds of millions of dollars in federal funds and staff layoffs, amid "volatile external environment,โ€ Interim President says.

Florida AG Threatens Lawsuit Against US Masters Swimming Over Male Participation in Female Events

FL AG James Uthmeier, in a letter to CEO of U.S. Masters Swimming, called for immediate end to male athletes participating in female competitions by organization.

The Marketโ€™s Focus Returns to Tariffs

Surging tariff revenue is expected to help the Treasury Department better manage the federal government budget deficit.

EUโ€™s Trade Chief to Meet With US Officials as EU Braces for Tariff Showdown

The EUโ€™s trade leader is headed to Washington for face-to-face negotiations with the Trump admin, a spokesman for the economic bloc said.

Nvidiaโ€™s AI Chip Sales to China Tied to Rare Earths Trade Talks, Says Commerce Secretary

USsโ€™ decision to allow Nvidia to resume selling China AI chips is tied to recent trade negotiations over rare-earth exports, according to Sec Lutnick.

Trump Says USโ€“Vietnam Trade Deal Nearly Complete

President Trump said the trade deal between the United States and Vietnam was nearly complete, the same day he announced a new deal with Indonesia.

Washington Announces Investigation Into Brazilian Trade Practices, Digital Payment Services

U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer announced the opening of an investigation into Brazilโ€™s โ€œunfairโ€ trading practices on July 15, 2025.
spot_img

Related Articles