Federal Appeals Court Upholds Constitutionality of Gun Bans for Drug Users

Contact Your Elected Officials

The court majority says history supports disarming drug users while a dissenting judge said the ruling sets a low bar and flouts common sense.

A federal appeals court has ruled that a law barring people who regularly use illegal drugs from owning guns is constitutional because of longstanding concerns about public safety, but ordered a lower court to take a closer look at whether disarming a Pennsylvania man who smokes marijuana violates his individual Second Amendment rights.

In a split opinion issued on July 14, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled in a case involving Erik Harris, who was charged under federal statutes after buying three handguns while regularly using marijuana.

Harris, then 21, falsely stated on federal firearms purchase forms that he was not an unlawful user of marijuana, according to court filings. Days after buying one of the guns, he went out drinking and after getting high, lost the firearm while partying and later reported it stolen.

โ€œWhen Harrisโ€™s missing gun turned up in a felonโ€™s hands, officers called Harris in for questioning,โ€ the opinion states. โ€œThere, he admitted that he smoked marijuana regularly, including earlier that same day.โ€

Harris pleaded guilty to possessing firearms as an unlawful drug user and making false statements on firearms forms but preserved his right to appeal. He argued that the gun ban for unlawful drug users violates the Second Amendment and is unconstitutionally vague.

Writing for the majority, Judge Stephanos Bibas held that history and tradition support laws disarming people whose drug use would likely cause them to pose a danger if armed. โ€œGuns and drugs can be a lethal cocktail,โ€ Bibas wrote, while citing foundation-era laws that allowed authorities to disarm people who were dangerously drunk or mentally ill, finding them relevant historical analogues for modern restrictions.

However, the court found there were not enough factual findings to decide whether Harrisโ€™s own marijuana use made him dangerous enough to justify stripping him of his Second Amendment rights. The court vacated his conviction in part and remanded the case for further proceedings.

โ€œToday, we hold that history and tradition justify … restrictions on those who pose a special danger of misusing firearms because they frequently use drugs,โ€ the opinion reads. โ€œBut we lack enough facts to tell whether the lawโ€™s restrictions are constitutional as applied to Harris.โ€

By Tom Ozimek

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Donald Trumpโ€™s Appointments Are Being Obstructed

Donald Trump is the only President in history that has had recess appointments blocked by his own party!

Trump Flag-Burning Ban: Unconstitutional, Un-American, and Trifling

Trump signed an EO to criminalize the burning of the American flag โ€” the right to do which having already been adjudicated by the highest court in the land.

Using True Facts of History to Determine What is Right and What is Wrong

The amount of time separating a human act from a truthful description of it is not as important as the veracity of historians bringing it to light.

The Very British Stalemate: British Politics Explained for Americans

The assumption in the minds of American commentators, politicians, and analysts is that the UK has "gone to the dogs" with "woke" political ideology.

NFL Vikings Male Cheerleader Controversy ย 

The NFL under the leadership of Roger Goodell is back to yet another controversy that is causing backlash and a possible boycott.

HHS Threatens to Cut Funds for 46 States Over Gender Ideology in School Curricula

HHS ordered 46 U.S. states and territories to remove all educational references to gender ideology from federally funded school grant programs within 60 days.

Interior Department Plans to Revoke Permit for $11 Billion Maryland Offshore Wind Farm

The Trump administration is preparing to revoke a Biden-era permit for an $11.5 billion offshore wind farm planned off the coast of Maryland.

Kraft, Coca-Cola Defeat Lawsuit Over Ultra-Processed Foods

Judge dismissed lawsuit against major food and beverage manufacturers, ruling teenager who sued did not meet evidentiary standards for suit to proceed.

Judge Dismisses Trump Admin Lawsuit Against Federal Court in Maryland

Trump admin lost lawsuit against federal court in Maryland that's automatically blocking deportations for illegals who challenged their detention by fed govt.

Commerce Secretary Says Pentagon Weighing Equity Stakes in Defense Contractors

DOD is weighing taking equity stakes in defense contractors such as Lockheed Martin and others, Commerce Sec. Howard Lutnick said in an interview.

Hereโ€™s What Major American Retailers Are Saying About Tariff Impacts

American retailers are doing what they can to keep tariffs from affecting consumers, but they acknowledge that eventually something has got to give.

Trump Threatens Tariffs for Nations With Digital Taxes on US Tech

The president said other countriesโ€™ digital taxes and regulations were โ€˜all designed to harm, or discriminate against, American Technology.โ€™

On 4th Anniversary of Afghan Attack, Trump Honors Soldiers Lost in US Withdrawal

President Trump welcomed Gold Star families and issued a proclamation honoring military lives lost during withdrawal from Afghanistan.
spot_img

Related Articles