IN-DEPTH: Trump Indictment Rests on Untested Legal Theory, Experts Say

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

The indictment of former President Donald Trump for holding military documents and obstructing the government from taking them is built on a novel legal theory that has multiple weaknesses, according to several lawyers and other experts.

The case has been portrayed in the media as being about Trumpโ€™s retaining classified documents from his presidency. However, the charges sidestep that issue and instead use a clause in the Espionage Act that criminalizes a failure to hand over national defense information. The indictment further alleges that Trump and staffer Waltine Nauta hid some documents when the government demanded them through a subpoena.

The alleged Espionage Act violations impose a high burden of proof and raise the question of whether the statute should have been applied to begin with and, if not, whether the underlying investigation should serve as a basis for obstruction charges, some lawyers told The Epoch Times.

โ€œThe key legal issue here is the interplay between the Presidential Records Act and the Espionage Act,โ€ said Will Scharf, a former federal prosecutor.

The Presidential Records Act of 1978 stipulates that after a president leaves office, the National Archive and Records Administration (NARA) takes custody of all his official records.

The law allows former presidents to keep personal documents such as โ€œdiaries, journals, or other personal notesโ€ not used for government business.

โ€œIf a former President or Vice President finds Presidential records among personal materials, he or she is expected to contact NARA in a timely manner to secure the transfer of those Presidential records to NARA,โ€ NARAโ€™s website states.

However, the Presidential Records Act isnโ€™t a criminal statute. If a former president refuses to turn over some documents or claims obviously official documents as personal, the worst he could face is a civil lawsuit.

Thereโ€™s little case law on such matters. In 2012, Judicial Watch tried to force former President Bill Clinton to turn over dozens of interview tapes he kept from his presidency. Clinton claimed the tapes were personal and the court sided with him. Judge Amy Berman Jackson, an appointee of President Barack Obama, went so far as to argue that the court had no way to second-guess a presidentโ€™s assertion of what is and isnโ€™t personal.

Byย Petr Svab

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

MyPillowโ€™s CEO Mike Lindell Wins 2 Court Cases

A federal court tossed the $5M ruling against Mike Lindell, saying arbitrators rewrote the rules of his 2021 Cyber Symposium challenge.

Whatโ€™s The Most Realistic Scenario In Which The West Might Replace Zelensky?

Yermak and Budanov agreed with the Anglo-American Axisโ€™ proposal to replace Zelensky with Zaluzhny and โ€œresetโ€ Ukraineโ€™s ties with the West.

Earned vs. Owed

Not since the Donner Party has a group of people so badly misinterpreted the circumstances of their situation like the players of the WNBA.

Just How American are Americaโ€™s Elite Schools?

Their exteriors may be ivy clad, but that faรงade on Americaโ€™s elite universities cloaks secrecy, power politics and globalist attitudes as well.

Multiple Democrats Playing Defense

There is a news situation going on that is...

Vaccination Rates Drop Among Kindergartners as Exemptions Increase: CDC

Rates of vaccination among kindergartners ticked down in the 2024โ€“2025 school year, the CDC said as the number of exemptions rose.

Boeing Featured in Nearly All US Trade Dealsโ€”Hereโ€™s Why

The skies are clearing for Boeing these days as it emerges as the clear winner of trade deals during the tariff negotiations between the US and its trading partners,

72 Arrested, 29 Human Trafficking Victims Rescued Across Mississippi: Officials

Mississippiโ€™s AG announced that it carried out a statewide operation in July that resulted in 72 arrests and the rescue of 29 human trafficking victims.

NASA, SpaceX Launch Crew-11 to Space Station

SpaceXโ€™s Falcon 9 rocket took off on Aug. 1, as the 11th act of the NASA commercial crew program set off for the International Space Station.

Trump Orders Firing of Labor Statistics Chief After July Jobs Report

President Donald Trump announced on Aug. 1 that he has directed the termination of the commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

Trump Issues 60-Day Deadline for Drug Makers to Lower Prices

Trump told CEOs of worldโ€™s leading pharmaceutical companies that he expects them to implement Most Favored Nation drug pricing within 60 days.

Trump Hikes Tariffs on Canada to 35 Percent

Trump followed through on his threat to raise tariffs on Canada from 25% to 35% saying country โ€œfailedโ€ to stop flow of fentanyl and other drugs into US.

Bessent Says Trump Accounts for Kids Are Backdoor โ€˜For Privatizing Social Securityโ€™

Treasury Sec Scott Bessent said Trump Accounts are โ€œa back door for privatizing Social Security,โ€ but the admin is committed to protecting Social Security.
spot_img

Related Articles