LIVE UDPATES: Trump Attends Appeals Hearing on Presidential Immunity Claims

Contact Your Elected Officials

An appeals court will hear arguments on Trumpโ€™s claim that he is immune from prosecution over his challenge of the 2020 election. Follow here for live updates.

By Sam Dorman

Here what’s happening:

  • Trump Says Case Opens ‘Pandora’s Box’
  • Argument Ends
  • Opening the ‘Floodgates’?
  • Trump Lawyer Begins Rebuttal
  • Main Question in Case
  • ‘Extraordinarily Frightening’ Consequences: Pearce
  • Pearce Addresses Jurisdiction
  • Special Counsel’s Team Begins Argument
  • Judge Questions Scope of Presidential Immunity
  • Trump Lawyer Not Challenging Smith’s Authority
  • Marbury v. Madison
  • Trump Lawyer Argues Trump’s Conduct Was Not Private Act
  • Charging a President for Official Acts Opens ‘Pandora’s Box’: Trump Lawyer
  • Appeals Hearing Begins
  • Trump Arrives
  • Jack Smith Arrives
  • Trump to Attend Appeals Court Hearing on Presidential Immunity Claim

Trump Says Case Opens ‘Pandora’s Box’

Trump spoke after the hearing, describing it as a โ€œmomentous day.โ€ โ€œWe have a great argument,โ€ he said. DOJ, he said, conceded certain points that should have ended the case. He added that the prosecution by โ€œBidenโ€™s DOJโ€ was โ€œvery unfair.โ€

Trump also defended himself, saying he โ€œdid nothing wrong,โ€ and emphasized the need to combat voter fraud.

โ€œI feel that as a president you have to have immunity, very simple,โ€ he said.

โ€œI think they feel this is the way they’re going to try and win and that’s not the way it goes. It will be bedlam in the country. Itโ€™s a very bad thing. It’s a very bad precedent. As we said, it’s the opening of a Pandora’s Box.โ€

President Trumpโ€™s attorney John Lauro offered comments as well.

โ€œFirst of all, this was a momentous day. This is the first time in our nationโ€™s history that a sitting president has decided to prosecute his major opponent whoโ€™s leading in all the polls,โ€ he said.

Mr. Lauro added that the president was being prosecuted โ€œfor carrying out his responsibilities, doing his job as president.โ€

โ€œWe canโ€™t have a country where every four years thereโ€™s a cycle of political recrimination.โ€

Argument Ends

Judges Pan and Childs asked questions about the implications of Trumpโ€™s argument before Mr. Sauer asked the three-judge panel to reverse the lower courtโ€™s decision.

The hearing took roughly 75 minutes.

Opening the ‘Floodgates’?

Mr. Sauer argued that Mr. Pearce forecasted a situation where the floodgates will be opened.

This DOJโ€™s prosecution was dangerous, he suggested, because it was a situation where the administration of Trumpโ€™s chief political opponent was prosecuting him.

That situation was โ€œtailor-made,โ€ he said, to produce โ€œcycles of recrimination.โ€

Trump Lawyer Begins Rebuttal

Mr. Sauer urged the court to focus on constitutional provisions surrounding the immunity argument. The indictment didnโ€™t reference anything after Trump left office, he said.

According to Mr. Sauer, the “frightening” future Mr. Pearce referenced is the one America has lived under for the last 235 years.

Main Question in Case

Judge Pan asked whether this case boil down to whether Trump was correct in interpretation of the impeachment judgment clause in Constitution?

Mr. Pearce agreed that was the main issue, saying that textual, structural, historical, and practical reasons pointed to Trumpโ€™s team being wrong.

‘Extraordinarily Frightening’ Consequences: Pearce

Mr. Pearce referenced Judge Panโ€™s earlier hypothetical whether a president can use SEAL Team 6 to assassinate a political rival.

He said that and other hypotheticals represented an โ€œextraordinarily frightening future.โ€

Pearce Addresses Jurisdiction

Even if a dismissal on jurisdiction might move the case faster, which would serve the special counsel’s aims, thatโ€™s not the right analysis, Mr. Pearce said.

He asked the court to reach the merits of the case even amid doubts about jurisdiction.

Special Counsel’s Team Begins Argument

Attorney James Pearce argued that the president has a unique constitutional law but is not above the law. The president didnโ€™t enjoy immunity after leaving office, he said.

“Separation of powers principles, constitutional text, history precedent and other immunity doctrines all points to the conclusion that a former President enjoys no immunity from criminal prosecution,” Mr. Pearce argued.

“At a minimum, this case in which the defendant is alleged to have conspired to overturn the results of a presidential election is not the place to recognize some novel form of criminal immunity.”

Judge Questions Scope of Presidential Immunity

Judge Florence Pan asked about balancing the need for presidential protection and public interest.

โ€œIt seems to me that there are some other article II interests here that are countervailing,โ€ she said, noting the executive vesting clause and law enforcement.

President Trumpโ€™s position was not fully aligned with the institutional interests of the executive branch, she suggested.

Trump Lawyer Not Challenging Smith’s Authority

Judge Childs asked about brief challenging Special Counsel Smithโ€™s authority.

Mr. Sauer said it raises very โ€œpowerful questionsโ€ but his team hadnโ€™t yet raised those.

Marbury v. Madison

The indictmentโ€™s scope โ€“ Everything alleged in the indictment is a presidential act, Sauer argued. END

Judge Karen Henderson raised a distinction between ministerial and discretionary acts outlined in the 1803 Supreme Court case of Marbury v. Madison.

Mr. Sauer responded that distinction has been held for subordinate officers. Nothing in this case can be remotely described as ministerial, Sauer argued. Even if that distinction goes up to the president, it wouldnโ€™t save the indictment, he added.

Judge Henderson responded, saying Sauer was missing what she was asking. She said itโ€™s โ€œparadoxicalโ€ to say Trumpโ€™s constitutional duty to execute laws allowed him to violate criminal law.

Mr. Sauer argued that everything alleged in the indictment is a presidential act.

Trump Lawyer Argues Trump’s Conduct Was Not Private Act

Judge Michelle Childs noted that the DOJโ€™s indictment alleged Trumpโ€™s conduct was private rather than official acts.

Mr. Sauer, in response, argued DOJโ€™s legal theory was wrong and foreclosed by Supreme Court precedents.

Charging a President for Official Acts Opens ‘Pandora’s Box’: Trump Lawyer

Trump attorney Mr. Sauer argued that charging a president for his official conduct opens a โ€œpandoraโ€™s boxโ€ for which this nation โ€œmay never recover.โ€

Judge Florence Pan asked whether a president could sell government secrets and avoid prosecution. She also asks whether a president can order SEAL Team Six to assassinate a political rival.

Mr. Sauer contended that a president should be impeached and convicted by Congress. The founders, he said, were worried about the abuse of the criminal process for political purposes. โ€œThatโ€™s exactly what we see in this case,โ€ he adds.

Mr. Sauer clarified that a president could be subject to criminal prosecution after impeachment and conviction by the Senate.

Appeals Hearing Begins

The Appeals Court hearing commenced with Trump attorney John Sauer defending the courtโ€™s jurisdiction to hear the appeal. An amicus brief had challenged this point.

The special counsel’s office is represented by James Pearce.

Trump Arrives

President Trump has entered courtroom at the E. Barrett Prettyman federal courthouse in Washington just before oral argument is set to comment.

Jack Smith Arrives

Special Counsel Jack Smith has arrived at the E. Barrett Prettyman courthouse in Washingron ahead of the appellate hearing in President Trumpโ€™s D.C. case.

Trump to Attend Appeals Court Hearing on Presidential Immunity Claim

A three-judge panel is set to hear former President Donald Trumpโ€™s appeal of a lower court decision rejecting claims that some of his actions on Jan. 6, 2021, were protected by presidential immunity.

Scheduled for Jan. 9, itโ€™s the second major appeal of the Justice Departmentโ€™s (DOJ) prosecution of President Trump in D.C. The former president will make an appearance at the hearing.

President Trump confirmed on Jan. 8 that he would attend, stating, โ€œOf course, I was entitled, as President of the United States and Commander in Chief, to Immunity. I wasnโ€™t campaigning, the Election was long over.โ€ (Read Full Article)

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Armistice and amnesiaโ€ฏย 

In case you missed it too, June 25thโ€ฏmarked the 75th anniversary of the beginning of the Korean War โ€“ the first hot front of the Cold War.โ€ฏ

Candace Owens Gets Sued by Macrons

Candace Owens began a deep dive into the lives of French President Emmanuel Macron, his wife Brigitte, and the story of how they came to be together.

Fluoride โ€˜Tabletsโ€™ For Babies EXPLODE in Popularity Amid Water Fluoridation Rollbacks

Reportedly, NPCs are so distraught that their toddlers wonโ€™t be fed a neurotoxin through the public water supply that theyโ€™ve resorted to fluoride pills.

ChatGPT Goes Biblical about End Times!

There are some truly outstanding internet content creators, or...

Bangkok Indians: โ€˜You Are Lucky Manโ€™

In Bangkok, friendly prostitutes outside โ€œmassageโ€ shops tell me Iโ€™m โ€œso handsome man.โ€ Indian men prowling those streets tell me Iโ€™m โ€œlucky man.โ€

Education Department Probe Finds 5 Virginia School Districts Violated Title IX

Five school districts in No. VA violated Title IX by allowing students to access โ€œintimate, sex-segregated facilities based on subjective โ€˜gender identity,โ€™โ€

Washington State Sues to Prevent Trump Admin From Accessing Food Aid Immigration Data

Washington state is suing financial services company Fidelity Information Service to prevent it from sharing food aid data with the federal government.

5 Things to Know About Trump Adminโ€™s Settlement With Columbia University

Under agreement between President Trump and Columbia regarding anti-Semitism, school will pay a $200 million fine to regain federal money.

Trumps America: Welpโ€ฆ that backfired.

The official @TheDemocrats account posted chart with the caption โ€œTrumpโ€™s Americaโ€ โ€” but didnโ€™t seem to notice how their own graph actually works.

Ex-DOJ Officials File Lawsuit Against Bondi Over Terminations

Former DOJ officials filed lawsuit against AG Bondi and the fed. govt, saying they were terminated for work on cases related to Jan. 6 Capitol breach.

Odds of U.S.-EU Trade Deal Are 50โ€“50 Ahead of Tariff Deadline: Trump

President Donald Trump said thereโ€™s a 50โ€“50 chance that the United States will finalize a trade deal with the European Union before an Aug. 1 deadline.

Trump Pulls Habbaโ€™s Nomination for New Jerseyโ€™s Top Prosecutor, Making Her Acting US Attorney

President Trump withdrew his nomination of Alina Habba to serve as NJโ€™s top federal prosecutor, making her Acting US Attorney.

Trump Says He Wants Muskโ€™s Companies to โ€˜Thrive Like Never Beforeโ€™

On Thursday, President Trump said, โ€œI want Elon, and all businesses within our Country, to THRIVE, in fact, THRIVE like never before!โ€
spot_img

Related Articles