No More Special Counsels

Contact Your Elected Officials
City Journal Header

Itโ€™s past time to put an end to one of the most destructive regimes in American law enforcement.

Few innovations in American law enforcement have done more damage than โ€œindependentโ€ prosecutors. Independent and special counsels have upended every presidential administration that has encountered them. They have never yielded benefits commensurate with their costs. They should be abolished.

From my perch at the White House Counselโ€™s Office, I was a front-row observer of, and direct participant in, Robert Muellerโ€™s investigation of Donald Trump. What I saw then confirmed to me the fatal flaws of the special-counsel regimeโ€”flaws that, by now, should be obvious to everyone.

The current special-counsel regulation dates to 1999, the year Congress allowed to expire the Ethics in Government Act of 1978, which inaugurated the role of independent counsel. That 1978 statute, a post-Nixon ethics reform, created โ€œindependent counselsโ€ who, once appointed, wielded the โ€œfull power and independent authority to exercise all investigative and prosecutorial functions and powers of the Department of Justice.โ€ These independent counsels reported to nobody, and they could only be removed for โ€œgood causeโ€ and โ€œby the personal action of the Attorney General.โ€

By the turn of the century, this regime had achieved bipartisan notoriety, spurring multiple Supreme Court cases, prompting perhaps Justice Antonin Scaliaโ€™s finest opinion (his solo dissent in Morrison v. Olson), and enabling the endless prosecutorial stalking of executive-branch officials.

Congressโ€™s letting the independent-counsel statute expire should have ended the matter. Yet rather than make a clean break, the Department of Justice made a grave, if understandable, error. It adopted a regulation maintaining independent prosecutors but housing them within the Department of Justice under the supervision of the Attorney General. The department believed it was improving the lapsed statute by continuing to exempt these โ€œspecial counselsโ€ from the attorney generalโ€™s โ€œday-to-day supervision,โ€ while making such prosecutorsโ€”unlike independent counselsโ€”ultimately answerable to the attorney general for their investigative and prosecutorial actions.

Experience has proved this system to be no better. For one thing, it does not solve the biggest problem with independent prosecutorial officesโ€”that prosecutors and agents join teams dedicated to pursuing a specific person or group of people. In these supremely political investigations, people who are politically hostile to the investigatory target invariably jump aboard.

By James Burnham

Read Full Article on City-Journal.org

Manhattan Institute
Manhattan Institutehttps://manhattan.institute/
The Manhattan Institute works to keep America and its great cities prosperous, safe, and free.

Transitioning from Regulatory Sclerosis to Arbitrary State Capitalism

The Trump administration is moving from reducing the size and regulatory power of the federal government to the formation of State Capitalism.

Gen Z and Crystallized Intelligence

Weโ€™ve created a new malaise: media fatigue and information overload, or โ€œdata smog,โ€ which has sharply accelerated in recent years.

Meet the Fairy From Hell in Charge of Vaccines at CDC Until Last Week

Picture the creepiest leather-daddy gimp at your local Prideโ„ข festival. Thatโ€™s this guy, Demetre Daskalakis, who ran the entire federal govt vaccine program.

The Clinton-Epstein Connection We Did Not Know

One attorney's inside info about D.C. and the relationship the Clintonโ€™s had with the late child sex pedophile Jeffrey Epstein

Faith under fire

Over half of historyโ€™s 70M Christian martyrs were killed in the 20th century, amid totalitarian regimes, purges, and ethnic violence.

Unqualified Secret Service Snipers Protected President, Inspector General Finds

Secret Service snipers who worked at events involving President Biden in 2024 failed to complete annual requirements showing they can hit targets.

Grand Jury Declines to Indict Woman Who Threatened Trump

A grand jury has declined to indict a woman who threatened President Donald Trump on social media, her lawyers said on Sept. 1.

Trump Admin Violated Law With Troop Deployment in LA, Judge Rules

A federal judge in California has ruled that the Trump administration unlawfully used Marines and National Guard troops in Los Angeles.

Kentucky Ends In-State College Tuition for Illegal Immigrants After DOJ Lawsuit

Kentucky agreed to end a policy that had allowed illegal immigrants to access in-state college tuition rates, following a lawsuit by the DOJ.

Trump Announces Space Command Moving to Alabama

โ€œI am thrilled to report that the U.S. Space Command headquarters will move to beautiful Huntsville, Alabama,โ€ President Trump said.

Trump Takes Aim at Crime in Chicago After Dozens Shot Over Weekend

President Trump said that he will โ€œsoonโ€ take actions to deal with crime in Chicago, weeks after he sent National Guard troops to Washington, D.C.

Trump Says India Offered Zero Tariffs After Decades of โ€˜One-Sidedโ€™ Trade

President Trump said India offered to cut tariffs on U.S. goods to zero, calling it a long-overdue fix for decades of one-sided trade.

Trump Says He Will Issue Executive Order to Require Voter ID

โ€œVoter I.D. Must Be Part of Every Single Vote. No exceptions!โ€ Trump wrote on a post on Truth Social. โ€œI Will Be Doing An Executive Order To That End!!!โ€
spot_img

Related Articles