North Carolina Supreme Court Allows Bars to Sue State Over COVID-19 Restrictions

Contact Your Elected Officials

Then-Gov. Roy Cooper issued an executive order shutting down bars but later allowed some bars to remain open.

The North Carolina Supreme Court ruled 5-2 in a pair of decisions that bar owners may pursue their lawsuits against the state over COVID-19-related shutdowns in 2020.

The similar rulings in the cases of Howell v. Cooper and North Carolina Bar and Tavern Association v. Stein were issued on Aug. 22.

In both cases, the state supreme court held that bar owners should be allowed to pursue their claims that the state policy ran afoul of the state-constitutional right to the “fruits of their own labor.” Both cases were sent back to lower courts for trial.

The North Carolina Supreme Court had agreed in June 2024 to consider the appeals after the Court of Appeals of North Carolina found in April that there was no evidence to support the decision of then-Gov. Roy Cooper to force some bars to shut down during the pandemic while allowing others to stay open.

In an executive order in March 2020, Cooper directed all bars in North Carolina to shut down. Two months later, he signed a new executive order that permitted bars inside restaurants to reopen but required others to remain closed.

The first executive order might have been reasonable, but the second was irrational, the Court of Appeals found.

Attorneys for the state argued the holding was wrong because Cooper’s orders forcing bars to shut down but then allowing some to stay open were lawful because they were “rationally related to a proper governmental purpose.”

In the North Carolina Supreme Court’s new ruling in Howell v. Cooper, the court majority held that those challenging the executive orders had sufficient evidence “to support the alleged violations of their rights to earn a living.”

The court also rejected the state’s claim that the lawsuit was barred by sovereign immunity.

Sovereign immunity is a legal doctrine that prevents governments from being sued unless they consent to being sued. The sovereign immunity of U.S. states is enshrined in the 11th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

The court majority said that although the pandemic era “was a chaotic period of time,” the governor “was not the only person facing uncertainty.”

By Matthew Vadum

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Chambers of Horror

Using a shutdown to legislate is like using a flame thrower to light a candle, it provides light momentarily but destroys everything in its path.

Government Shutdown, Health Care, Tax Breaks=Perfect Storm

The shutdown over cuts to health subsidies for the poor stems from Trump’s OBBB plan, which critics say funneled trillions to the wealthy.

3I/Atlas Comet or UFO Arrives Tomorrow!

The 3I/Atlas object is hurtling toward our solar system on a strange path and composition, set to pass behind the sun, obscuring visual and radio tracking.

‘I’d Be Finished’: Vaccine Researcher Trashes Own Study to Save Career

Most doctors comply with the system, following orders to keep their jobs, income, and prestige, even if it means setting aside independent judgment.

Kamala, Please Run Again

Kamala Harris hinted she wants to run for President in 2028, despite poor poll numbers and her loss in 2024. If she runs, the big winners will be the GOP.

Government Shutdown Could Cost US Economy $14 Billion: CBO

The government shutdown could cost the U.S. economy up to $14 billion, a new analysis by the CBO said on Oct. 29.

Trump Says SNAP Benefits Will Be Solved for Next Month

President Trump said that he believes Republicans will solve how to fund food stamps, when he was asked about the SNAP and the government shutdown.

Pennsylvania Democrats’ Voter Registration Edge Shrinks Again

State records show the Democratic lead fell from about 686,000 in 2020 to about 178,000 by May 2025, and to 60,000 in the latest count.

Virginia Announces Alternative Food Stamp Program as SNAP Deadline Looms

Virginia is starting a state food stamp program as SNAP faces suspension amid the federal shutdown, pending new congressional funding.

Trump, Japanese PM Sign Critical Minerals, Rare Earths Deal

The U.S. president visited Tokyo on the second leg...

Trump Hikes Canada’s Tariffs by 10 Percent for Not Pulling Anti-Tariff Ad Immediately

Trump announced he will increase tariffs on Canada by 10% after ad by provincial government of Ontario misrepresented President Reagan’s speech on tariffs.

Trump Rolls Back Emissions Rules on Copper Smelters

President Trump issued a proclamation aimed at reversing a Biden-era environmental rule that enforced stricter air emission standards on copper smelters.

Donor Gives $130 Million to Cover Shortfall in Troop Pay During Shutdown

Trump announced on Oct. 23 that an anonymous donor sent $130M to cover military pay during the ongoing government shutdown.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central