Supreme Court to Consider Sentence Reductions for Men Convicted of Armed Robbery

Contact Your Elected Officials

Two prisoners argue they would have been entitled to shorter sentences if the First Step Act had existed when they were tried.

The Supreme Court will consider whether prisoners sentenced before the First Step Act was enacted are entitled to have their sentences reduced to match standards established by the seven-year-old law.

The bipartisan legislation approved by Congress and signed by President Donald Trump in 2018 reformed aspects of the criminal justice system, making it easier for the courts to reduce penalties for certain offenders.

The Supreme Court granted the petitions on June 6 in Rutherford v. United States and Carter v. United States in an unsigned order. No justices dissented. The court did not explain its decision.

The two men who brought these appeals argue that individuals who are sentenced nowadays face mandatory minimum imprisonment terms of shorter durations than they would have been given before the First Step Act took effect. Mandatory minimum sentencing laws take away judges’ discretionary authority and require specific minimum periods of incarceration for certain crimes.

Convicted before the enactment of the First Step Act, the prisoners applied under a federal compassionate release statute for sentence reductions after the First Step Act took effect. Courts denied their requests.

The compassionate release statute allows a court to scale back a sentence if it determines there are “extraordinary and compelling reasons” justifying relief, according to a summary of petitioner Daniel Rutherford’s petition filed with the Supreme Court.

Section 994 of 28 U.S. Code states that rehabilitation of a prisoner by itself may not count as an “extraordinary and compelling” reason. That statute also says an “extraordinary and compelling” reason also has to be consistent with policy statements issued by the U.S. Sentencing Commission, the summary said.

Sections 401 and 403 of the First Step Act provided reduced penalties going forward for certain firearm and drug offenses.

“Because of these changes, individuals sentenced today for these offenses often face mandatory minimum terms of imprisonment decades shorter than they would have received before the First Step Act,” the summary states.

The Supreme Court has agreed to consider whether federal district courts may consider the disparities in sentences created by the First Step Act if “extraordinary and compelling reasons” justify a sentence reduction under the compassionate release statute. Six federal courts of appeals allow federal district courts to factor in the disparities, while four courts of appeals do not, the summary said.

By Matthew Vadum

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Are conservatives fighting a fiction of woke?

Wokery, it hurts to say it, is too disorganized to have an organized cosmology or doctrine of metaphysical belief.

Illinois Democrat Offenders Reveal Party

The crime of J.B Pritzker and Brandon Johnson in this episode of American history is called subversion at the least , but could be as serious as treason.

Inside the Public School Librarian Jihad to Keep Transgender Propaganda on Shelves

Public school librarians are doing all they can to keep child tranny propaganda flowing directly into the malleable minds of their charges.

Five Reasons Why The Latest Czech Elections Were So Important

Populist-nationalist politician Andrej Babis is poised to return to the premiership after his party's victory. Here are 5 reasons why this is so important.

Bad Bunny is the NFL’s Latest Insult

After years of advocating social justice causes, the NFL chose left wing, gender fluid rapper Bad Bunny to headline the next Super Bowl. Does the NFL want conservatives fans?

29-Year-Old Florida Man Arrested Over Palisades Fire

A 29-year-old Melbourne, Florida man was arrested for allegedly starting the Palisades wildfire that burned for weeks and killed 12 people.

FBI, LAPD Raid Mexican Mafia-Linked Gang in Southern California

FBI and LAPD raided a Mexican Mafia-linked gang in Southern CA, arresting a dozen individuals in connection to the Rancho San Pedro organization.

James Comey Pleads Not Guilty to 2 Federal Charges

Former FBI Dir. James Comey pleaded not guilty in federal court on Oct. 8 to charges of making a false statement and obstructing a congressional proceeding.

Judge Upholds Nassau County Ban on Transgender Athletes in Women’s Sports

A New York judge on Oct. 6 upheld a Long Island county law banning male athletes from participating in women’s sports at county-run facilities.

Trump Says He May Invoke Insurrection Act in Portland If Necessary

President Donald Trump on Oct. 6 said he may consider invoking the Insurrection Act in Portland, Oregon, if necessary.

Trump: All Medium, Heavy Duty Trucks Entering US Will See 25 Percent Tariff on Nov. 1

President Trump announced on Monday that all medium and heavy-duty trucks entering the United States will see a 25 percent tariff starting on Nov. 1.

Treasury Names Social Security Commissioner as CEO of IRS

Treasury Sec. Scott Bessent announced that Frank Bisignano, the head of the Social Security Administration (SSA), will also serve as CEO of the IRS.

Agencies Terminated, Descoped 94 Wasteful Contracts With $8.5 Billion Ceiling Value, Says DOGE

Various federal government agencies have terminated and descoped 94 wasteful contracts over the past five days, DOGE said in an Oct. 4 post on X.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central