Supreme Court to Consider Sentence Reductions for Men Convicted of Armed Robbery

Contact Your Elected Officials

Two prisoners argue they would have been entitled to shorter sentences if the First Step Act had existed when they were tried.

The Supreme Court will consider whether prisoners sentenced before the First Step Act was enacted are entitled to have their sentences reduced to match standards established by the seven-year-old law.

The bipartisan legislation approved by Congress and signed by President Donald Trump in 2018 reformed aspects of the criminal justice system, making it easier for the courts to reduce penalties for certain offenders.

The Supreme Court granted the petitions on June 6 in Rutherford v. United States and Carter v. United States in an unsigned order. No justices dissented. The court did not explain its decision.

The two men who brought these appeals argue that individuals who are sentenced nowadays face mandatory minimum imprisonment terms of shorter durations than they would have been given before the First Step Act took effect. Mandatory minimum sentencing laws take away judgesโ€™ discretionary authority and require specific minimum periods of incarceration for certain crimes.

Convicted before the enactment of the First Step Act, the prisoners applied under a federal compassionate release statute for sentence reductions after the First Step Act took effect. Courts denied their requests.

The compassionate release statute allows a court to scale back a sentence if it determines there are โ€œextraordinary and compelling reasonsโ€ justifying relief, according to a summary of petitioner Daniel Rutherfordโ€™s petition filed with the Supreme Court.

Section 994 of 28 U.S. Code states that rehabilitation of a prisoner by itself may not count as an โ€œextraordinary and compellingโ€ reason. That statute also says an โ€œextraordinary and compellingโ€ reason also has to be consistent with policy statements issued by the U.S. Sentencing Commission, the summary said.

Sections 401 and 403 of the First Step Act provided reduced penalties going forward for certain firearm and drug offenses.

โ€œBecause of these changes, individuals sentenced today for these offenses often face mandatory minimum terms of imprisonment decades shorter than they would have received before the First Step Act,โ€ the summary states.

The Supreme Court has agreed to consider whether federal district courts may consider the disparities in sentences created by the First Step Act if โ€œextraordinary and compelling reasonsโ€ justify a sentence reduction under the compassionate release statute. Six federal courts of appeals allow federal district courts to factor in the disparities, while four courts of appeals do not, the summary said.

Byย Matthew Vadum

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Alligator Alcatraz: A Bold Step Toward Secure Borders

Alligator Alcatraz funded through FEMA, represents a decisive move by the Trump admin to address illegal immigration with efficiency and resolve.

Is America Broke?

Silicon Valley investor and economic commentator Balaji Srinivasan made...

Hungary: Prideโ„ข Cometh Before the Color Revolution

The EU engaged in a diplomatic siege of the Eastern European nation-state of Hungary pressuring it into embrace global trannyism or face wrath of Brussels.

Understanding the Trump/Musk Feud

The passion Trump and Musk exhibit over the OBBB is not contrived or for show. Each is addressing the problem from completely different approaches.

Whoโ€™s Your Mamdani?

Former state assemblyman Mamdani, a failed rapper, has repackaged himself as a "democrat socialist." In laymen's terms he's a Socialist. Way to go Democrats!

US Economy Adds 147,000 New Jobs, Unemployment Rate Dips to 4.1 Percent in June

The U.S. job market remained strong in June, as labor conditions continued to hold up amid economic uncertainty.

Bryan Kohberger Pleads Guilty in Stabbing Deaths of 4 University of Idaho Students

Bryan Kohberger, charged in the stabbing deaths of 4 University of Idaho students in 2022, entered a guilty plea deal to spare him the death penalty.

Judge Blocks Trumpโ€™s Order Barring Illegal Border Crossers From Claiming Asylum

A federal judge ruled against a Trump administration policy that blocks foreign nationals who cross the U.S.-Mexico border from seeking asylum.

The Dollar Dilemma During Trump 2.0

The U.S. dollar index, a gauge of the buck against currencies including the euro and the yen, has declined by almost 11% to its lowest level in 3 years.

White House Report Reveals Top Earners, Staffers Working for No Salary

The Trump admin released its yearly report that shows the salaries for White House staffers, also revealing officials who arenโ€™t accepting salaries at all.

Bessent: US, India Near Agreement to Lower Tariffs

The United States and India are โ€œvery closeโ€ to a trade agreement, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Tuesday.

Federal Agencies Terminate Contracts With Springer Nature

Multiple federal agencies ended contracts with Springer Nature, publisher of journal Nature, according to spokespersons and a govt database.

Investors Shrug Off Prospects of Higher Tariffs as US Stocks Post Record High

Wall Street shrugged off the prospects of higher U.S. tariff rates as stocks registered all-time highs to finish the raucous second quarter.
spot_img

Related Articles