Supreme Court to Review Alabama’s Death Row Case Concerning IQ Test

Alabama officials sought to execute Joseph Clifton Smith, who was convicted and sentenced to death for a 1997 murder before his sentence was overturned.

The Supreme Court said on Friday that it will consider how courts should weigh multiple IQ tests when assessing a death row defendant’s claim of intellectual disability, in a case tied to an Alabama death row inmate.

The court granted Alabama’s petition to clarify whether and how courts should evaluate the “cumulative effect of multiple IQ scores” in assessing an Atkins claim—which prohibits the execution of individuals with intellectual disabilities—according to its website.

Alabama officials sought to execute Joseph Clifton Smith, who was convicted and sentenced to death for a 1997 murder before his sentence was overturned by lower courts due to his intellectual disabilities.

Alabama accepts an intelligence quotient (IQ) score of 70 or below as part of the legal test used to establish a person’s intellectual disability.

According to the court filings, Smith had five IQ test scores, with the lowest being 72—which is above Alabama’s cutoff for an Atkins claim. But lower courts said that Smith’s IQ could be as low as 69 because of measurement errors and that other evidence of mental disability existed.

The Eleventh U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the judge’s conclusions in 2023, setting aside Smith’s death sentence. This prompted Alabama officials to file their appeals to the Supreme Court in the case.

Earlier this year, Alabama filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to review the lower court’s decision and clarify “how and why courts should conduct an ‘analysis multiple IQ scores jointly’” when evaluating an Atkins claim.

“As the State’s expert testified, five IQ tests provide a more reliable estimate of the test-taker’s true IQ than one test alone,” the petition stated. “Accordingly, a court should account for the conjunction of an offender’s scores, rather than rely on what each score might suggest separately.”

By Aldgra Fredly

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

The Looming Threat To Our Homeland

After success of “Operation Midnight Hammer,” where U.S. military bombed Iranian nuclear facilities, the threat to America has never been greater.

Groundhog Day came late this year to the Land of Smiles.

it’s the same rigmarole, on whatever pretext, the army commandeers the Thai state with vague promises to restore democracy at some unspecified future date.

Resource number one

Russia has an unsustainable birthrate worsened by mortality rate of Russian males through war and alcoholism. One solution, steal young children from other countries. 

Expansionist CCP Runs Amok in Pacific After U.S. Relocates Naval Assets to Mid-East

Caveat established, China’s been going bananas on the high seas as the eyes of the world, and U.S. military assets, hone in on Iran.

The Anti-Trump Protests – Why Are They So Important?

The anti-Trump stance is not a political position, but a desperate gesture, a mental diagnosis of those who refuse to accept the reality of the World today.

Mawson study using Florida Medicaid data again confirms childhood vaccines are likely responsible for nearly 80% of the autism cases in US

Mawson study using Florida Medicaid data again confirms childhood vaccines are likely responsible for nearly 80% of the autism cases in US.

Abbott Signs Bill Into Law Requiring Ten Commandments in Public School Classrooms

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced he signed a bill into law, that would require all public school classrooms in his state to display the Ten Commandments.

Supreme Court Limits Factors Courts May Consider When Revoking Supervised Release

On June 20, the Supreme Court voted 7–2 to limit the factors that judges are allowed to consider when revoking supervised release.

Reports: B-2 Stealth Bombers Depart United States, Heading West

Reports indicate multiple U.S. Air Force B-2 Spirit stealth bombers departed Whiteman Air Force Base, MS, overnight on June 20 and June 21, heading west.

No Changes Planned for FDA’s Vaccine Advisory Committee ‘At This Time’: Spokesperson

There are no plans to remove any members of the panel that advises the FDA on vaccines, a spokesperson said on June 20.

Trump Says Trade Deals Expected With India and Pakistan

President Trump expects US will sign trade deals with India and Pakistan, signaling growing momentum in push to reshape global trade through tariff diplomacy.

Trump Says US Intelligence Community’s Assessment of Iran’s Nuclear Program ‘Was Wrong’

President Trump said his director of national intelligence’s assessment in March that Iran had yet to decide on building a nuclear weapon was wrong.

NIH Ends Gain-of-Function Research, Implementing Trump’s Executive Order

The NIH announced the end of gain-of-function research. The institute’s update said the move is in compliance with President Trump’s EO on the topic. 
spot_img

Related Articles