The Montana Supreme Court Tries to Move the State Left

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

The Montana Supreme Court’s overruling of election integrity laws is part of a wider pattern.

The Epoch Times reported on March 28 that the Montana Supreme Court struck down four state “election integrity” laws.

The court’s decision appears to be part of a wider judicial effort to reverse conservative electoral trends in Montana.

Manipulating elections might not seem like a proper role for a court. And it’s not. But as I detailed in an Epoch Times column on Dec. 4, 2023, the Montana Supreme Court has a record of extreme overreach. I described how the justices have made themselves almost unreviewable by exercising an absolute veto over the state constitutional amendment process.

The Montana Supreme Court may be the most bizarre appeals bench in the United States. Along with extreme activism, it frequently exhibits leftward bias and legal incompetence. And, as explained below, perhaps a touch of corruption.

The Court’s Record

I have followed the Montana Supreme Court for many years. In 1990, I wrote my first scholarly article on its case law. I produced major studies in 2012 and 2018 and again in 2024. Although my initial impression (reflected in the 1990 study) was favorable, experience gradually changed my views.

Over time, I learned that the justices’ treatment of legal issues, and particularly constitutional issues, often was sub-par.

I also learned about the court’s leftward political bias. The easiest way to see this bias is to examine how the court treats contested ballot issues. In the years since 1982, it has upheld liberal ballot issues without exception, but almost without exception has struck down conservative ones.

Montana lawyers have told me the court works in tandem with groups that promote left-wing causes and contribute to the justices’ reelection campaigns.

More recently we have seen traces of actual corruption surface. In 2021, it came to light that for decades, the court’s administrator allegedly had been involved in illegal lobbying at taxpayer expense. An ensuing legislative subpoena produced a mass of emails supporting this conclusion. Then the justices shut down further discovery. In response to the administrator’s request, they quashed the legislative subpoena on a Sunday, without—as due process requires—giving the Legislature an opportunity to be heard.

By Rob Natelson

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

President Trump’s UN Message: Strength in an Age of Folly 

President Donald Trump delivered a speech at the UN General Assembly this week that was equal parts indictment and invitation.

Zelensky Is Manipulating Trump Into A Disaster Of Epic Proportions

Trump’s flip-flop on Ukraine is leading to Trump's manipulation by Zelensky into a disaster of epic proportions if Trump doesn’t soon wise up.  

Pregnant TikTok Goblins Gobble Tylenol, Demand #AutismAcceptance

HHS Sec. RFK Jr. and President Trump announced findings that Tylenol use in pregnant women and babies may be associated with increased risk of autism.

Fox News Exploits MN Church Massacre to Push AI ‘Early Intervention’ Crime Suppression

Don’t let the technocrats’ performative empathy and calls for prayer in aftermath of a man-made disaster deceive; dead kids are golden opportunities for the national security state.

Grit over glamor: the tranquil excellence of D-III college football

Division-III football is where walk-ons become captains, and linemen become legends. Next time you pass a small college stadium, stop in.

DHS to Bolster Security at ICE Offices After Dallas Attack

DHS said agency will bolster security at its field offices and facilities in after shooting at an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Dallas.

Starbucks to Cut 900 Jobs, Shutter Underperforming Stores

Starbucks will eliminate approximately 900 jobs and close underperforming stores in North America as part of corporate restructuring efforts.

US National Guard Surpasses 2025 Recruitment Targets

The National Guard has exceeded its recruiting goals for fiscal year 2025, the Department of War (DOW), said in a Sept. 24 statement.

Kenvue Responds to Old Tylenol Posts on Social Media

Posts on social media stating Tylenol has not been tested during pregnancy and is not recommended for pregnant women are being taken out of context.

Trump to Host Turkish President Erdogan to Discuss Trade, Defense

President Trump will welcome Turkish President Erdogan to the White House on Sept. 25 to discuss a Boeing deal and bilateral issues.

Trump Announces New Executive Order to Dismantle Antifa

President Donald Trump announced on Wednesday that he would be signing a new executive order to dismantle Antifa networks in the United States.

Trump Hangs Portrait of Joe Biden Autopen in New White House Presidential Wall of Fame

President Donald Trump hangs portrait of Joe bidden autopen in new White House Presidential Wall of Fame after joking about doing so in an interview.

Trump Warns Against Globalist Agendas in UN Address, Holds Bilaterals

President Trump speaks at the 80th anniversary of the UN, with the gathering focused on “peace, development, and human rights.”
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

MAGA Business Central