Trade Negotiations Aren’t Chess, Poker, or Go. They’re Bridge.

Trade negotiations are often mischaracterized as adversarial contests akin to warfare or chess. (The latter is increasingly invoked in varying degrees: 3d, 4d, and nth degree). Headlines speak of countries “battling” over tariffs or “outmaneuvering” each other in the global marketplace. But while those analogies may be emotionally satisfying and undergird ideological fervor, they fundamentally misunderstand and distort the nature of trade itself.

Unlike war, trade is not about conquest; it’s about cooperation under constraints. While no analogies are perfect, within the gaming milieu, a better model is to be found in contract bridge, where strategy, communication, and shared outcomes dominate the pursuit of mutual gain.

First and foremost, trade does not inherently require government interference. In its most natural form, trade arises spontaneously—sua sponte—as individuals, firms, and even nations engage in voluntary exchange to pursue their own interests, each party judging for itself whether a given transaction is mutually beneficial. The complexity and strategic posturing captured in-game analogies only enters the picture when states either seize the authority to control trade from private actors or when a population willingly delegates that authority to a political entity. It is in this shift—from decentralized decision-making to centralized negotiation—that trade becomes the province of diplomats, regulators, and strategists, subject to tariffs, quotas, and geopolitical calculation rather than pure market coordination. Once trade becomes a matter of policy rather than private action, the dynamics necessarily change—requiring negotiation, coordination, and a high tolerance for ambiguity.

Bridge, like trade, requires signaling, risk management, and long-term thinking. Played in partnerships, success in bridge is only achievable when players work together to interpret incomplete information, anticipate reactions, and align their strategies toward a common objective. No matter how skilled one player is, they cannot win alone. In trade negotiations, simply trying to extract concessions by brute force is likely to fail, either immediately or in time. Agreements must be structured to hold, function, and deliver net benefits to both sides. Even in a zero-sum context on specific issues (like market access or rules of origin), the broader objective is always positive-sum: increase the flow of goods, reduce frictions, and enhance economic welfare broadly.

That stands in contrast to the chess or poker metaphors often used. Chess is zero-sum and strictly competitive; a gain for one side is necessarily a loss for the other. There is no scope for joint benefit and no reason to cooperate. That model may describe military conflict or geopolitical jockeying, but it fundamentally misunderstands trade negotiations, where voluntary exchange and mutual advantage are foundational principles. Contract bridge also captures the asymmetry and complexity of trade negotiations. Optimally, countries enter trade talks not to dominate but to discover overlapping interests and convert them into stable, enforceable agreements.

By Peter C. Earle and Subiksha Ramakrishnan

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Columns

Harvard’s China Ties Under Scrutiny as US Targets Student Visas

Following Trump admin’s action to vet Chinese nationals studying in US for ties to the CCP, Harvard's involvement with Beijing has come to the fore.

The Russian-Ukrainian Talks Are At An Impasse That Only The US Or Brute Force Can Break

The second round of Russian-Ukrainian talks in Istanbul resulted in no progress and talks are at an impasse that only the US or brute force can break.

Airline Crews Say DEI Persists, Despite Safety Concerns and Trump Orders

During a 2024 conversation, a flight instructor described an “egregious” example of standards apparently being relaxed to meet DEI goals.

The Ghosts Performing Biden’s Presidential Duties

Since June 2021, we has been hunting for the ghosts performing Biden’s presidential duties due to his diminished mental capacity.

Is There a New England Serial Killer? Social Media Says Maybe, Police Say No.

A social media post suggested the possibility of 6 bodies buried at Black Point near Scarborough Beach, each positioned vertically and facing the ocean.

News

Texas Man Arrested for Allegedly Trespassing at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Resort

A Texas man was arrested after allegedly scaling the perimeter fence of President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida, according to the Secret Service.

Judge Says Education Department Remains Barred From Canceling COVID-19 School Aid

Judge issued order preserving preliminary injunction blocking DOE from rescinding extensions to states for accessing COVID-19 funds for school districts.

Federal Judge Dismisses DNC Lawsuit Against Trump Administration

A U.S. District judge dismissed lawsuit by DNC claiming President Trump would harness power of the executive branch to interfere in upcoming elections.

US Private Sector Adds 37,000 Jobs in May, Trump Urges Fed to Lower Rates

Payroll processor ADP reported that private employers rose by 37,000 in May, marking the smallest increase since March 2023.

Arizona Governor Vetoes Bill Banning China From Purchasing Land in the State

Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs vetoed bill that would have prohibited the Chinese communist regime and state-owned enterprises from acquiring property in Arizona.

US Charges 2 Chinese Nationals With Smuggling Crop-Killing Fungus, Visa Fraud

Two Chinese citizens, one who works at Univ of Michigan, were charged with visa fraud, conspiracy, false statements, and smuggling a pathogen into US.

Doctor Recounts Tiananmen Tragedy and the Medical Aid That Was Blocked by the CCP

A former Hong Kong legislator and neurologist recounts Tiananmen tragedy and medical aid that was blocked by the Chinese Communist Party.

House CCP Committee Chairman Inquires With Canadian Firm About Supply of Critical Metal

Rep. John Moolenaar sent letter to Canada company Almonty Industries to inquire about a critical metal essential for US defense technology.
spot_img

Related Articles