‘Truth By Committee’: Lessons From the NPR Melodrama

Contact Your Elected Officials

“I wish I had a schilling,
For every senseless killing,
I’d buy a government.
America’s for sale,
And you can get a good deal on it,
And make a healthy profit,
Or maybe tear it apart,
You start with assumption,
That a million people are smart,
Smarter than one”
-NOFX, The Decline

Without hyperbole, one would be hard-pressed to imagine a more damning set of former affiliations and employers than those on NPR goon Katherine Maher’s resume. The only missing institutions to round out the smorgasbord of absolute evil are Raytheon and Goldman Sachs (although she did work for HSBC as well, which is morally equivalent to Goldman Sachs).

Via City Journal:

“Katherine Maher has a golden résumé, with stints and affiliations at UNICEF, the Atlantic Council, the World Economic Forum, the State Department, Stanford University, and the Council on Foreign Relations. She was chief executive officer and executive director of the Wikimedia Foundation. And, as of last month, she is CEO of National Public Radio.)”

(As a side note, it has been under-reported that Maher occupies a board position on Signal, which should give anyone who uses the app pause to reconsider how confidential their messages therein actually are.)

          RelatedThe 2021 American ‘Left’ Is Now Undeniably a Cult

On the independent media circuit, the Katherine Maher ultra-progressive totalitarian story has been run into the ground, but here’s what I believe is a fresh angle on it in the form of a bit of excellent analysis offered by Harrison Smith of InfoWars regarding how the leftist hive mind views the merits of freedom of speech, depending on who or what is doing the speaking.

For some background, Smith’s analysis, which I’ll get into in a moment, was based on the following resurfaced comments by Maher to the Atlantic Council in 2021 vis a vis Wikimedia’s censorship regime targeted at the speech of unsanctioned individuals:

See video above.

We took a very active approach to disinformation and misinformation, coming into not just the last election, but how we supported our editing community in an unprecedented moment where we were not only dealing with a global pandemic but a novel virus, which by definition means we know nothing about in real-time. And we’re trying to figure it out as the pandemic went along.
We really set up, in response to the pandemic but also the upcoming U.S. election as a model for future elections outside of the U.S., including as number happening this year.
The model was around how do we create a clearinghouse of information that brings the institution of the Wikimedia Foundation with the editing community in order to be able to identify threats early on, through conversations with government, of course, as well as other platform operators to understand what the landscape looks like…

The number one challenge here that we — we see is of course, the First Amendment in the United States is a fairly robust protection of rights and — and that is a protection of rights both for platforms, which I actually think is very important, that platforms have those rights to be able to regulate what kind of content they want on their sites, but it also means that it is a little bit tricky to really address some of the real challenges of where does bad information come from, and sort of the influence peddlers who have made a real market economy around it.”

          RelatedNPR’s Mind-Rot Logic: ‘Even the Truth Can Be Misinformation’

Maher avows her support above for what Smith describes as “truth by committee,” meaning essentially that the institution is deserving of free speech protections because it is more easily managed and co-opted than an individual, who is definitionally less predictable and more prone to “go rogue” than an institution.

The institution can be technocratically managed through several mechanisms of control, like:

  • Advertising pressures
  • State sanctions (see: Section 230 for social media companies)
  • Fiduciary responsibility to shareholders
  • Blackmailed or bribed board members
  • Groupthink

As such, an institution “ruled by committee” will almost never spontaneously take a stand on anything based on a moral calculation or any other cause; it will only act in the manner that the institutional incentives dictate that it acts.

This is, incidentally, also why the ruling class despises Donald Trump and has sought to undermine his political career from the start.

Unlike literally any of his predecessors from at least the past forty years, Trump came up on the presidential candidate scene as an unsanctioned upstart. He did not receive the blessing of the donor class to run, nor was he vetted and groomed by the intelligence community. His electoral power was derived from that fact that he caught fire with the grassroots — the kind of populist power that the ruling class fears above all.

Given his provenance and his base of support, he is viewed by the power structure with deep suspicion, just as any individual is freed from the constraints of institutional control.

Ben Bartee, author of Broken English Teacher: Notes From Exile, is an independent Bangkok-based American journalist with opposable thumbs.

Follow his stuff via Substack. Also, keep tabs via Twitter.

For hip Armageddon Prose t-shirts, hats, etc., peruse the merch store.

Support always welcome via insta-tip jar.

Ben Bartee
Ben Barteehttps://armageddonprose.substack.com/
BEWARE!!! Ben Bartee never minces words, so read at your own risk. Ben is a Bangkok-based American journalist, grant writer, political essayist, researcher, travel blogger, and amateur philosopher -- with opposable thumbs. He is the author of Broken English Teacher: Notes From Exile.

Child-Diddling Migrant Invokes Curious ‘I Thought She Was My Wife’ Defense

Convicted of groping a sleeping schoolgirl on a flight, Javed Inamdar offered bizarre defenses that made O.J. Simpson’s glove excuse seem credible.

What’s The Real Reason Why The Economist Wants Europe To Spend $400 Billion More On Ukraine?

The Economist urges Europe’s elites to fund Ukraine’s $390B recovery, arguing it’s cheaper than facing the costs of inaction over the next four years.

Fourth and funded: The business of buyouts

Through week ten of the college football season, the ledger on what universities owe their former coaches in buyouts was nearly $185 million. 

Deflating Portland: Why Antifa Went from Black Blok to Inflatable Costumes

Antifa's transformation from militant to mascot is so absurd it's almost comedic. Yet beneath the humor lies something calculated. It’s all about optics.

The Affordable Care Act: The Great Deception of “Affordable”

When the Affordable Care Act was introduced, people trusted what they were told. The truth is, the ACA has done the exact opposite of what it claimed.

FAA Cutting Air Traffic at 40 Major Airports by 10 Percent Amid Government Shutdown

FAA is cutting air traffic by 10 percent at 40 major airports amid the ongoing government shutdown, citing safety reasons.

US Steel, Nippon Steel Announce $11 Billion Investment Over 3 Years

U.S. Steel announced a $14 billion plan with Nippon Steel to modernize and expand operations to boost growth and competitiveness in the steel industry.

Child Among 11 Dead From UPS Plane Crash at Louisville Airport

A young child and ten others died when a UPS cargo plane crashed at Louisville Muhammad Ali International Airport, according Gov. Andy Beshear.

Judge Orders Prosecutors to Turn Over Evidence Against James Comey

A federal judge on Nov. 5 ordered prosecutors from the DOJ to hand over evidence in its case against former FBI Director James Comey.

Trump Drafting Executive Order on Election Integrity After Alleging Ballot Fraud in California

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said an executive order is being drafted to strengthen U.S. elections and curb mail-in ballot fraud.

Trump Re-Nominates Jared Isaacman for NASA Administrator

Trailblazing civilian astronaut Jared Isaacman is once again President Donald Trump’s choice for NASA’s administrator.

US Agencies Terminate 103 Wasteful Contracts With $4.4 Billion Ceiling Value: DOGE

Government agencies canceled 103 wasteful contracts worth $4.4 billion, saving $103 million in five days, according to the Department of Government Efficiency.

Food Stamp Payments Could Restart by Wednesday as Ordered by Judge: Bessent

The Trump administration awaits court decisions on funding food stamp benefits for low-income Americans amid the ongoing government shutdown.
spot_img

Related Articles