Who Are Climate Change Deniers?

Contact Your Elected Officials

By Glenn Spitzer (November 4, 2023)

Who are these โ€œclimate change deniersโ€ we hear so much about? Does anyone really doubt the climate changes?

Well, yes. There are climate change deniersโ€”a lot of them. They live right under our noses, and they are celebrated. Hereโ€™s a quote from one of the most famous climate change deniers:

โ€œOur civilization has never experienced any environmental shift remotely similar to this. Todayโ€™s climate pattern has existed throughout the entire history of human civilization.โ€

That was Al Gore in 2007. According to Gore, the climate was โ€œshiftlessโ€ for thousands of yearsโ€”a paradigm of stability.

Goreโ€™s quote was a restatement of Michael Mannโ€™s 1998 โ€œhockey stick theory.โ€ Mann argued that the Earthโ€™s climate held steady for all of human history (the hockey stick handle) until suddenly in the 1900s the temperatures increased, representing the upturned blade of the hockey stick.

Mannโ€™s theory is the basis of the modern CO2-focused โ€œglobal warmingโ€ movement, which ironically morphed into the โ€œclimate changeโ€ movement. Mannโ€™s theory informs the positions taken by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the agency dictating policy to your local, state, and federal governments.

The most important assumption in Mannโ€™s theory is that there was no climate change prior to the 20th century. But this assumption is false. It is climate change denial; it is the sacrifice of truth for a desired outcome.

Mannโ€™s 1998 study intentionally ignored several thousand scientific publications showing other periods of climate change throughout human history, such as the Medieval Warm Period (about 900 AD to 1300 AD), the Little Ice Age (about 1300 AD to 1915 AD), and the Roman Warm Period (about 1 AD to 500 AD). Despite claims of perpetual stability, it turns out the climate is always changing.

Scientists estimate that, during the Medieval Warm Period, for example, the temperatures in parts of Europe were 1.0-1.4ยฐ Celsius (1.8 โ€“ 2.5ยฐ Fahrenheit) warmer than they are now. (Oliver, 1973; Fagan, 2000; Fagan, 2007; and Singer and Avery, 2007). Oxygen isotope studies in China, Germany, Greenland, Ireland, New Zealand, Switzerland, and Tibet, as well as tree-ring data from many sites throughout the world, confirm the Medieval Warm Period. The studies are so numerous (several thousand published papers confirming this warming), that it raises the obvious question: โ€œWhy do climate activists deny that the climate is always changing?โ€

There are two important reasons why activists deny climate change. First, the acceptance of prior warming periods undermines the argument that a modern warming is an existential threat; and second, prior warming periods undermine the idea that anthropogenic (manmade) CO2 is the primary cause of climate change.

The Medieval Warm Period is a particularly inconvenient truth for the modern climate activists because it shows warming has beneficial effects on humanity. As the European region became warmer, agriculture spread and generated food surpluses. The European population doubled. In short, the Medieval Warm Period underscores the reality that, while humans struggle in colder weather, we generally thrive in warmer weather. In other words: no crisis justifying extraordinary intervention.

But more importantly, what does a constantly changing climate say about the effects of anthropogenic CO2?

The fact that the climate has been changing significantly for thousands of years (actually millions) begs the question: what causes climate change? This is a messy question. Activists seek to foreclose options by addressing causation through simple correlation. If climate change is only a recent phenomenon, one that began coincidentally with the rise in anthropogenic CO2, then causation is simple.

However, if this fact pattern is a fiction, then the correlation argument falls apart. When we understand the climate is always changing, and was changing well before the rise of anthropogenic CO2, then we are confronted with the reality that other factors are at play. Anthropogenic CO2 is placed in proper context as a potential factor of uncertain significance. Importantly, when simple correlation no longer drives our analysis, we are freed to assess other causal factors more seriously.

When people acknowledge that anthropogenic CO2 could not possibly cause climate change throughout human history, they are forced to question their religion. When guided by truth instead of ideology, the following questions become more interesting:

  • How is it that the last six great ice ages started with far more CO2 in the atmosphere than we have now?
  • Is it true, as many experts note, that temperatures drive CO2 levels, and not the other way around?
  • How does anthropogenic CO2 drive climate when it makes up less than 5% of total CO2 (with most coming from the oceans, volcanoes, decaying vegetation, and forest fires)?
  • Isnโ€™t the sun the most important cause of climate, and what effects follow from sun spots and solar flares?
  • If greenhouse gases (GHGs) are the most significant drivers of climate change, then why do we focus on CO2, when water vapor (i.e., clouds) is a far more impactful GHG? (In fact, there have been a flurry of recent published studies on the effects of clouds.)

For many in science, self-preservation and status remain subordinate to truth and courage. Many have sacrificed research funding and reputation to criticize Mannโ€™s theories, including IPCC lead authors John Christy (former NASA climatologist) and Richard Lindzen (former MIT professor). In fact, numerous climate experts upended their professional lives by pointing out that Mannโ€™s theory is more activism than fact (including Professors Tim Ball, Ian Clark, Ian Plimer, Nir Shaviv, Piers Corbyn, Steven Koonin, Judith Curry, and William Happerโ€”to name a few).

Experts Steve McIntyre and Ross McKitrick presented a detailed analysis of the flaws of Mannโ€™s 1998 theory in a series of studies in 2003 and 2005, detailing the numerous technical flaws with Mannโ€™s analysis. They found Mannโ€™s theory was invalid โ€œdue to collation errors, unjustifiable truncation or extrapolation of source data, obsolete data, geographical location errors, incorrect calculation of principal components and other quality control defects.โ€

In a 2014 paper, McKitrick summarized the theoryโ€™s most significant problem as an issue of unreliable proxy data. Namely, Mann relied on a small and controversial subset of tree-ring records of bristlecone pine cores from high and arid mountains in the US Southwest. The scientists who published the tree-ring data on which Mann relied (published by Graybill and Idso in 1993) specifically warned that the data should not be used for temperature reconstruction and that the 20th century data had regional anomalies.

The overarching takeaway here is that we cannot cede the power of thought to the โ€œexperts.โ€ Experts serve an important role in that they assist us in analyzing matters beyond our common understanding. But experts are mere fallible humans. When they are controlled by their biases, flawed in their analysis, or misguided by incorrect data, then we must reject their conclusions.

By Glenn Spitzer

About Glenn Spitzer

Glenn Spitzer is an environmental litigator who practices in California. He predominantly represents governmental agencies.

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

Corrupted Medical Societies Push SSRIs For Pregnant Women in Defiance of FDA

A recent expert panel organized by the FDA cast doubt on the safety of SSRIs โ€” even though these drugs are largely considered safe by healthcare providers.

The โ€œTrump Bridgeโ€ Could Lead To Russiaโ€™s Expulsion From The South Caucasus

If agreed to, and the report remains unconfirmed for now, the โ€œTrump Bridgeโ€ could lead to Russiaโ€™s expulsion from the South Caucasus.

Sweeney Swoon

Sydney Sweeney donned American Eagle jeans and hawked them as part the "Sydney's got great jeans" campaign, and the Left acted like she'd committed an atrocity.

Lay Democrats to Waste, Post Truths in Copy and Paste!

Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) humorously stated, โ€œOur secret plan for dealing with the Democrats is called, โ€˜Operation: Let them speak.โ€™โ€

Congress doesnโ€™t Care What the Average Person Thinks

In researching voting rights issues, a study provides a foundation for the statement โ€œgovernment officials donโ€™t care what people like them think.โ€

DHS Announces New Illegal Immigrant Detention Center โ€˜Speedway Slammerโ€™ Coming to Indiana

Gov. Braun partners with federal govt to continue mass deportation of illegals by expanding detention bed space at Indianaโ€™s โ€œSpeedway Slammerโ€.

US Will Build Nuclear Power Plant on Moon, Acting NASA Chief Duffy Says

NASAโ€™s Sean Duffy said the US was planning to build a nuclear reactor on the lunar surface as part of the Artemis campaign to return and stay on the moon.

Trump Says Some Deported Farm Workers Allowed to Return Legally

Trump admin is allowing some deported farm workers to return legally and preparing rules to broadly address farm labor shortages created by deportations.

Tennessee Police Nab Quadruple Murder Suspect After Multiple-Day Manhunt

Police in Jackson, Tennessee, have taken murder suspect Austin Robert Drummond into custody after a multiple-day manhunt.

Trump Raises India Tariffs to 50 Percent Over Russian Oil Imports

Trump imposed additional 25% tariff on India, lifting total rate to 50%, as Indiaโ€™s government directly or indirectly imports Russian Federation oil.

HHS Cancels 22 MRNA Vaccine Development Contracts

mRNA vaccine development contracts are being canceled and redirected because vaccines fail to protect against upper respiratory infections like COVID and flu.

Vance โ€˜Probably Favored at This Pointโ€™ for 2028 Nomination, Trump Says

Trump said Vance โ€œmost likelyโ€ leading contender to carry MAGA torch in 2028, calling him โ€œprobably favoredโ€ to become Republican presidential frontrunner.

Trump to Sign Order Penalizing Banks That Discriminate Against Conservatives

President Trump confirmed that he will sign an EO aimed at penalizing banks he claims have discriminated against conservatives, including himself.
spot_img

Related Articles