A Lesson from James Madison: Loose vs. Strict Construction of the Constitution

Contact Your Elected Officials

Are you for a strict or loose interpretation of our U.S. Constitution?

Suppose this question were asked in a national survey. A large percentage of people would probably identify themselves as supporters of loose interpretation of the U.S. Constitution. While it is true that today โ€œlooseโ€ is the popular stance, to the conservative there is only one way to interpret the U.S. Constitution: strictly.

Loose Construction

Those who read the Constitution and give its words a broad meaning are called loose constructionists. They look upon the document as something that needs to flex to be able to work and โ€œkeep upโ€ with the times. In order to do this, loose constructionists twist the words of the Constitution until they are far from their original meaning as written by the founders. The โ€œloose crowdโ€ deliberately misconstrue the โ€œnecessary and properโ€ clause as an excuse to expand the powers of the federal government. This clause reads:

The Congress shall have power to . . . make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing powers, and all other powers vested by this Constitution in the government of the United States, or in any department or officer thereof. [Article I, Section 8]

Strict Construction

On the other hand, strict constructionists interpret the Constitution as originally intended by the founders, keeping within the bounds of the document. Conservatives also know that a strict reading of the document is safer for their rights; for if we loosely interpret the Constitution, our rights can be just as loosely interpreted.

Necessary and Proper Clause

Many who quote the โ€œnecessary and properโ€ clause in defense of loose interpretation tend to focus on those three words, overlooking the rest of the clauseโ€”which says Congress can make these laws โ€œfor carrying into execution the foregoing powers, and all other powers vested by this government of the United States.โ€ By โ€œforegoing powersโ€ is meant the list of what Congress has the power to do (Article 1, Section 8). Some examples of these powers include to lay and collect taxes, provide for the common defense, coin and regulate the value of money, regulate commerce with other nations, and declare war. In other words, the โ€œnecessary and properโ€ clause merely gives Congress the power to enact the legislation needed for carrying out these duties listed.

Founding Father James Madison has this to say on the subject: โ€œIf the instrument [U.S. Constitution] be interpreted by criticisms which lose sight of the parties to it, in the fascinating pursuit of objects of public advantage or convenience, the purest motives can be no security against innovations materially changing the features of the government.โ€

And we should also keep in mind the times during which the Constitution was framed. The nation had just come through a long war against tyranny and for independence, in part because the colonists had resented the encroachments of big government. Is it reasonable that they would agree to set up a government carelessly granting Congress unlimited power? โ€œThis is not an indefinite government deriving its powers from general terms,โ€ Madison explained, โ€œ. . .but, a limited government tied down to the specified powers, which explain and define the general terms.โ€

Loose construction brings upon us gobs of laws (which are both unnecessary and unproper), tears away at the foundation of our God-given rights, and contradicts the foundersโ€™ intentions of the way a free government should function. Even in his day Madison warned, โ€œIf not only the means, but the objects [of the Constitution] are unlimited, the parchment had better be thrown into the fire at once.โ€

Bibliography:

Bowen, William R., et al. American Government in Christian Perspective, 3rd ed. Abeka Book, Inc., 2016.
Mattern, David B., ed. James Madisonโ€™s โ€œAdvice to My Country.โ€ University Press of Virginia, 1997.

Natalie Morris
Natalie Morris
Natalie Morris began her TTC column in 2021, recently publishing her 50th post. She enjoys writing about issues that affect average Americans (such as herself), as well as U.S. history and culture. She firmly believes that a day in which no writing is done is a day that is wasted.

Canada Forces Man to Remove Cameras From Private Property Amid Anti-Racism Push

Government expands its surveillance powers, while restricting citizens from monitoring their own property, citing concerns over โ€œracism.โ€

Are the E. Jean Carroll Lawsuits a RICO Case?

Trump lost his appeal in the E. Jean Carroll cases, leaving him liable for $83.3M. He plans to take the matter to the U.S. Supreme Court.

All Apologies For the Culture War Slop

"Forgive me for ignoring the elite-driven political/economic excesses, focusing instead on divisive culture war slop."

Rising sea levels are less of a threat than we were told

New study challenges climate alarmism: sea levels aren't rising faster than the past century, despite dire warnings of floods and mass migrations.

President Trump is Being Wrongfully Obstructed on Tariffs

Podcaster Zach De Gregorio, in โ€œWolves And Finance,โ€ delivers a sharp editorial unpacking the truth behind Trumpโ€™s international tariff policies.

Authors of โ€˜Astonishingโ€™ Study Showing Unvaccinated Kids Are Healthier Refused to Go Public With Results

Attorney Aaron Siri told the Senate a major study found vaccinated children were significantly more likely to develop chronic diseases.

US Government Imposes Sanctions on Cyber Scam Centers in Southeast Asia

U.S. govt has imposed sanctions on 19 individuals and entities for their alleged roles in an extensive network of scam centers in Burma and Cambodia.

DOJ Announces Federal Charges Against Suspect in Fatal Stabbing of Ukrainian Woman

DOJ charged man accused of fatally stabbing Ukrainian refugee on a light-rail in Charlotte, amid a growing national outcry over her murder.

Texas A&M Ousts 2 Officials After Student and Professor Clash Over Gender Identity Lesson

Texas A&M officials were removed and DOJ probe launched after video showed prof. dismissing student over gender lesson in children's literature class.

Trump Runs out of Patience With China, Sharpens His Words

President Donald Trumpโ€™s recent remarks targeting China and its allies mark a noticeable shift in tone.

Trump Signs Order Renaming Department of Defense as Department of War

President Donald Trump on Sept. 5 signed an executive order renaming the Department of Defense as the Department of War.

Trump Signs Executive Order Targeting Countries That Unlawfully Detain Americans

President Trump signed an EO on targeting the unlawful detention of American citizens around the world and to facilitate the release of hostages.

Trump Sends Warning to Venezuela After US Military Strikes Boat Allegedly Carrying Drugs

President Trump sent a warning to Venezuela after the U.S. military struck what the administration says was a boat carrying drugs in the Caribbean.
spot_img

Related Articles