Matthew Crawford Tells Congress to Defy the “Data Priests” in The New Atlantis

Singularity Weekly Header

The political philosopher’s arguments are summarized in “Defying the Data Priests” at The New Atlantis

Last summer saw a wave of enthusiasm for anti-trust legislation against Big Tech. One of the most eloquent conservative cases for breaking up this “classic infrastructure monopoly” was laid out by the physicist turned political philosopher, Matthew Crawford. Focusing on “smart home” technologies—which surveil Americans’ private lives in perverse detail—Crawford argues that Big Tech companies have become a form of government in their own right.

“Conservative legal scholars have long criticized a shift of power from Congress to the administrative state, which seeks to bypass legislation and rule by executive fiat, through administrative rulings. The appeal of this move is that it saves one the effort of persuading others, that is, the inconvenience of democratic politics.

“All of the arguments that conservatives make about the administrative state apply as well to this new thing, call it algorithmic governance, that operates through artificial intelligence developed in the private sector. It too is a form of power that is not required to give an account of itself, and is therefore insulated from democratic pressures.”

Crawford argues persuasively that these Big Tech firms have essentially made themselves a necessary component of American’s daily lives. As many have noted, the data they collect en masse is being aggregated and sorted by algorithms, essentially creating an automated social credit score.

“Mr. Zuckerberg has said frankly that ‘In a lot of ways Facebook is more like a government than a traditional company.’ If we take the man at his word, it would seem to raise the question: Can the United States government tolerate the existence of a rival government within its territory?”

The most alarming aspect of this rising corporate power is the nature of artificial intelligence itself. The cognitive pathways by which algorithms arrive at their conclusions are completely opaque to human beings—even to the people who program the neural net systems. AI is an alien mind. To the extent that algorithms determine our social credit, our employment, and our overall social structure, America is being ruled over by an alien intelligence.

Crawford puts forward a solid conservative argument for bringing these dangerous corporate powers to heel. In a constitutional republic, we are to be ruled by public consent, not by unelected technocrats and their alien creations. If Congress doesn’t intervene, Crawford contends, that’s the techno-dystopia we’re hurtling toward.

By Joe Allen

Read Original Article on Joebot.Substack.com

Matthew Crawford’s Testimony before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on Antitrust, Competition Policy & Consumer Rights

Matthew Crawford’s testimony was delivered to a hearing on smart home technology held by the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on Antitrust, Competition Policy & Consumer Rights, on June 15, 2021.

Matthew-Crawford-Senate-Judiciary-Testimony-Antitrust-Competition

About Mathew B. Crawford

Matthew B. Crawford is a senior fellow at the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture at the University of Virginia and a motorcycle mechanic and custom parts fabricator. He earned his B.S. in physics at the University of California at Santa Barbara and a Ph.D. in political philosophy from the University of Chicago. A contributing editor at The New Atlantis, Dr. Crawford has written for numerous publications, including The New York Times Magazine, The American Interest, and The Hedgehog Review. He is the author of Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work—which was named Editor’s Choice by the Financial Times of London—and, most recently, The World Beyond Your Head: On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction.

Substack
Substackhttps://substack.com/
Substack believes that great writers, bloggers, thinkers, and creatives of every background should be able generate income from their audiences on their own terms.

Columns

Trump’s Latest Angry Post About Putin Is His Most Significant One Yet

Trump’s latest angry post about Putin revealed how he perceives the Ukrainian Conflict. According to Trump, “[Putin] has gone absolutely CRAZY!

Trucking Industry Insiders Back Move to Bring Back English Proficiency Checks

U.S. govt is taking steps to close a legal loophole that allowed logistics companies to employ truck drivers who aren't necessarily credentials to do job.

President Trump is RIGHT to Defund Higher Ed!

Harvard is suing Trump Admin calling on court to restore research dollars after refusal to cooperate to combat Antisemitism and hate speech on campus.

Triumph for the American People as ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ Passes House

In a historic victory for President Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson, the U.S. House of Representatives passed a sweeping tax-cut and spending bill.

Choctaw Nation Honors Code Talkers Who Helped Turn the Tide in WWI

Shortly after enlisting, Oklahombi and 19 other Choctaw men became part of an effort using their language to help win the war for the Allies.

News

CDC Stops Recommending COVID Vaccine for Healthy Children, Pregnant Women

CDC will no longer recommend healthy children and pregnant women take COVID-19 vaccine shots, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced.

Supreme Court Won’t Hear Student’s Challenge to School Ban on ‘Two Genders’ Shirt

U.S. Supreme Court declined to accept a student’s challenge to a Massachusetts school’s decision to ban his “there are only two genders” T-shirt.

Prosecutors Seek 3-Year Sentence for Chinese Man Who Operated Secret Police Station in NYC

U.S. prosecutors are seeking three-year prison sentence for Chinese American citizen accused of operating a secret police station for Beijing in NYC borough of Manhattan.

FBI Deputy Director Bongino Says Bureau Looking at Several Cases Involving ‘Potential Public Corruption’

FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino said on Monday that the bureau is looking at launching investigations into cases of potential public corruption.

WHO Deems New COVID Strain a ‘Variant Under Monitoring’ Amid Resurgence in China

WHO said a new COVID-19 variant has been designated as a “variant under monitoring” amid reports indicating a resurgence of virus in mainland China.

California Utility Agrees to Pay $82.5 Million to Settle Claims From 2020 Fire

Southern California Edison reached a record $82.5 million settlement with U.S. to resolve claims from 2020 Bobcat Fire in Angeles National Forest.

Musk Says He Is Going Back to Working on His Companies After X Outage

Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk will resume working at his companies around the clock following a widespread outage of his social media platform X.

Key Vote Puts Texas Closer to Displaying Ten Commandments in Classrooms

Texas Legislature cleared a major vote on a measure that would require the state’s public school classrooms to display the Ten Commandments.
spot_img

Related Articles