Polling Predictions vs. Election Reality: A Model of Mistrust

Contact Your Elected Officials

In the 2024 presidential race, pollsters insisted the competition was too close to call in key swing states, with six out of seven states showing Harris and Trump within a 1% margin. Certainly, if these are unbiased polls the error would expect to swing in either direction. Based on these polls, a roughly equal likelihood existed for each candidate to outperform the polling predictions, especially within a typical 2-3% margin of error. But what actually happened?

The Results were not Random

On Election Day, Trump outperformed the final polls in all seven swing states by an average of 2.43% per state. While this figure falls near the margin of error, the pattern defies probability; itโ€™s statistically unlikely for all seven states to lean in one direction if the polls were truly unbiased.

Looking Beyond the Swing States

Expanding the analysis to the 31 states which had polling data published right up until election day (from FiveThirtyEight), the trend becomes even clearer: in 29 of those states, Trump exceeded poll predictions.ย Harris only surpassed the polls in two states.ย The average difference in election performance relative to the final poll results in those 31 states was 2.86%ย in Trumpโ€™s favor, when each state is weighted equally.ย When weighted by the number of electoral votes in each state, Trump outperformed the last poll results by an average of 3.77%. This broad skew raises questions about the methods and reliability of pre-election polling data.

Unpacking Bias in Polls

If poll data were unbiased, weโ€™d expect performance differences to form a bell curve centered around zero, about as wide as the margin of error of the poll. But as seen in this Figure, the distribution of actual performance relative to polls was anything but normal. This deviation suggests potential flaws in polling methodologies or, possibly, an agenda to shape rather than reflect public opinion.

Models vs Reality: Polls vs Vote Counts

Polls, like scientific models, aim to represent complex systemsโ€”in this case, predicting voter behavior based on limited data. However, these polls are an estimate based on assumptions or expectations, not an exact measure. The final results serve as a reality check, highlighting gaps in polling accuracy. So, is the issue simply a methodological inadvertent bias due to incorrect assumptions, or do pollsters consciously skew data to influence public perception?

Parallels with Climate Models

This discrepancy in polling accuracy resembles issues in climate change modeling. Both polling and climate predictions simplify complex systems to predict outcomes, relying on a limited set of variables while potentially overlooking critical factors. Just as climate models struggle with countless variables influencing global temperatures or CO2 levels, pollsters face the challenge of predicting voter behavior based on algorithm inputs and limited data sets. What variables need to be measured? How much weight should each variable be given? How are interactions between variables compensated for? Whether itโ€™s polls or climate models, there are guaranteed to be variables that would be impactful to the system but remain unknown or unmeasured.

The election system is big, but not as overwhelming as the earthโ€™s climate system. Polls also have an actual definitive result within a reasonable timeframe, meaning the actual election is going to give us certain data with which to evaluate the usefulness of the previous models (polls). Even with such a relatively small system, the polls are off the mark. How much more so with models of climate change.

โ€œHockey Stickโ€ Graphs

Plotting the final election results against pre-election polling data yields a โ€œhockey stickโ€ effectโ€”a sharp deviation between stable polling predictions and actual voter outcomes. This parallels the well-known โ€œhockey stickโ€ shape seen in climate data, where models show recent spikes in temperatures after centuries of stability. The problem with this type of graph is that results from a model (polls) are on the same graph as actual measured data (vote counting). Just as the hockey stick CO2 graphs include estimates of historical CO2 levels based on indirect measurements of ice core samples filtered through model โ€œalgorithmsโ€ alongside more recent measurements CO2 taken in real time. Both cases raise the question: are we witnessing actual huge changes in previously stable trends, or simply exposing inaccuracies in predictive models? 

Final Thoughts

As polling organizations analyze the model-reality gap, itโ€™s important for consumers to approach polling data critically to regain public trust. But do we need polls? Polls risk influencing voter behavior, potentially altering the outcome they aim to predict. If a candidate initiated a campaign for supporters to decline to participate in polls, the trustworthiness of polls could be intentionally quashed. Perhaps we would be in a better place if voters did not have the distractions of the polls, preserving a more independent decision-making process based on candidatesโ€™ values and policies.

Are we relying on modelsโ€”or on real insights to guide our decisions?

Mack Ransom
Mack Ransomhttps://www.drmackshack.com/
Dr. Mack Ransom explores overlooked scientific and cultural connections, blending his passion for science, Christian faith, and the pursuit of truth through his posts on Dr. Mack's Commentary Shack.

Is Epstein Still Alive?

They told us Epstein was dead. They showed us a cell, a bed sheet, a broken hyoid bone, but what followed wasn't justice it was the biggest cover up since 9/11.

Somali Minneapolis Mayoral Candidate Condemns White โ€˜Domestic Terrorists,โ€™ Demands $400 Million For โ€˜Anti-Racismโ€™

Soon-to-be democratic socialist mayor of Minneapolis, Omar Fetah, in 2021 demanded $400 million from taxpayers to invest in โ€œanti-racismโ€ measures.

Seventy-one, But Iโ€™m Still Not Done, LEARNING!

My favorite activities in life are thinking (learning) and laughing and it's been found that a โ€œsense of humorโ€ is a sign of higher intelligence.

Good Night And Good Riddance To The Late Show

Shocking announcement that The Late Showย with Stephen Colbert will officially cease production rocked the Democratic Party, as Colbert is a staunch supporter.

Coldplay Concert Offers Us Garden of Eden Moment

Adultery is still illegal in 10 states. It was illegal in 15 states just 30 years ago. There was a time when adultery was a crime in all 50 states!

School Districts Sue Trump Admin Over $6.8 Billion Funding Freeze

School Districts Sue Trump Admin saying freeze is illegal, while the admin says some grants had been designated for left-wing causes and ideological programs.

Court Blocks Mississippi From Enforcing DEI Ban in Schools

A federal court temporarily blocked Mississippi from enforcing a law against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices in educational institutions.

Robin Williamsโ€™s Eldest Son Remembers the Late Actor on His 74th Birthday: โ€˜Love You Foreverโ€™

Zak Williams, the son of late actor Robin Williams, penned a touching tribute to his father on Monday, celebrating what would have been his 74th birthday.

Pentagon Pulling 700 Marines Off LA Protest Response Mission

The Pentagon is continuing to wind down troop deployment to LA, withdrawing around 700 U.S. Marines who deployed last month in response to civil unrest.

US Reaches Trade Deals With Indonesia, Philippines

President Trump announced the US has reached a trade agreement with the Philippines that includes a 19% tariff on goods imported from Southeast Asian country.

Bessent Calls for Internal Review of Federal Reserveโ€™s Nonmonetary Policy Operations

U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Monday called for an internal review of the Federal Reserveโ€™s nonmonetary policy operations.

Trump Orders US Exit From UNESCO, Reversing Biden-Era Reentry

US will withdraw from UNESCO by end of 2026 citing ideological differences, an anti-Israel bias and โ€œglobalistโ€ agenda out of step with U.S. foreign policy.

Philippine President Marcos to Meet With Trump for Trade Talks

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. will meet with President Trump at the White House on Tuesday for bilateral talks focused on security and trade.
spot_img

Related Articles