Supreme Court Rules 9-0 Wisconsin Violated First Amendment by Denying Tax Exemption to Catholic Charity

Contact Your Elected Officials

A divided lower court previously ruled Catholic Charities is not exempt from unemployment tax because it is not โ€˜operated primarily for religious purposes.โ€™

The U.S. Supreme Court on June 5 ruled unanimously that Wisconsin violated the First Amendment by not granting a Catholic charity an exemption from paying unemployment tax.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote the 9โ€“0 opinion in Catholic Charities Bureau v. Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission.

Catholic Charities Bureau is a nonprofit organization that functions as an arm of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Superior, Wisconsin. The bureau oversees several other entities that render charitable services to communities across the state.

Wisconsin law excuses religious organizations that are โ€œoperated, supervised, controlled, or principally supported by a church or convention or association of churchesโ€ from paying state unemployment tax.

The petitioner, Catholic Charities, argued that it is unconstitutional to allow the state to decide what work is religious in nature.

โ€œThe First Amendment mandates government neutrality between religions and subjects any state-sponsored denominational preference to strict scrutiny. The Wisconsin Supreme Courtโ€™s application of [the state statute] imposed a denominational preference by differentiating between religions based on theological lines. Because the lawโ€™s application does not survive strict scrutiny, it cannot stand,โ€ the justice wrote.

Strict scrutiny is the highest level of review used by the courts. Under it, the government has to show that a law is narrowly tailored to advance a compelling governmental interest and that the law is the least restrictive way to serve that interest.

Sotomayor wrote that Wisconsin is not the only jurisdiction that exempts religious organizations from paying taxes to cover unemployment compensation programs. Since Congress in 1970 approved the Federal Unemployment Tax Act, which contains language similar to that found in the Wisconsin law, more than 40 states have adopted similarly worded tax exemptions.

The Supreme Court of Wisconsin held 4โ€“3 in March 2024 that Catholic Charities and its four related organizations that serve the developmentally disabled are not โ€œoperated primarily for religious purposes,โ€ so they fail to meet the requirements for a tax exemption.

That court held that the activities of Catholic Charities do not qualify as โ€œtypicalโ€ religious activities because the organization does not โ€œattempt to imbue program participants with the Catholic faithโ€ and because the help it provides to those with mental and developmental disabilities could be carried out by secular organizations.

Byย Matthew Vadum

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Epsteinโ€™s Niece Exposes the Illuminati!

There is a shocking interview by the podcaster Shaun Attwood, an English former ecstasy trafficker turned YouTube podcaster, speaker, activist, and author.

When Gynocrats Attack: Innocent Locker Room Talk Interrupted By Rabid Karen

The question posed: โ€œWho do you think has a...

Obamaโ€™s Treason is a Betrayal of American Democracy and Demands Real Accountability

Few scandals have cast a longer shadow than the 2016 Russia investigationโ€”the manufactured crisis by President Obama designed to cripple Trump's presidency.

Chronic Grievous Insufficiency

A president's physical vigor, stamina, and mental acuity are essential to his ability to fulfill the duties of office and those qualities should matter with no regard to party affiliation.

Russiagate – Obama’s Coup Against Trump?

I had little confidence in wrongs committed by D.C. official elites being rectified, but Gabbardโ€™s disclosures provides impetus for reassessment.

Oregon High School Athletes File First Amendment Lawsuit Over Podium Protest

AFPI filed lawsuit for Oregon high school athletes, alleging OSAA violated their First Amendment rights by punishing their peaceful protest of boy competing in girlsโ€™ event.

Professional Wrestling Legend, Hulk Hogan, Dies at 71

Hulk Hogan, former WWE superstar and one of the most recognizable figures in the sports entertainment industry, has died at 71 years old.

Pediatrician Group That Recommends Weight Loss Medications for Children Receives Money From Manufacturers: Study

AAP has taken in millions from companies manufacturing weight loss drugs, raising concerns about their endorsement of the drugs for children.

Declassified House Report Details โ€˜Substandardโ€™ Intelligence Methods Used in Russia Assessment

2020 declassified intelligence report found several intelligence reports suggesting Putin helped Trump leading to 2016 election were โ€œsubstandard.โ€

DOJ Forms Strike Force to Assess DNI Findings on Russia Collusion Allegations

DOJ is forming task force following the declassification of docs that shed light on origins of false claims that Trump won 2016 election with Russiaโ€™s help.

Trump Doesnโ€™t Support Government Doing Business With Muskโ€™s AI Company: White House

Trump is not interested in allowing the federal govt to do business with Elon Muskโ€™s AI company, WH press secretary Karoline Leavitt said on July 23.

Trumpโ€™s Tariffsโ€”A Closer Look at Who Pays and How

Since President Donald Trumpโ€™s return to the White House, tariffs have been the centerpiece of the administrationโ€™s economic agenda.

Trump Announces Trade Deal With Japan

With Aug. 1 deadline approaching, the US has reached a trade agreement with Japan, U.S. President Trump announced on social media on Tuesday.
spot_img

Related Articles