Supreme Court’s Decision on Nationwide Injunctions Leaves Open Potential Workarounds

Contact Your Elected Officials

States or nonprofits could still pursue broad relief through legal avenues such as class-action lawsuits.

The Supreme Court’s landmark decision on nationwide injunctions was a win for those who criticized the practice, which has been used to block the Trump administration’s policies since President Donald Trump returned to the White House. But, as some of the justices indicated, plaintiffs can still seek widespread blocks on the administration.

Republicans’ primary argument for ending nationwide injunctions was that they exceeded judges’ authority by providing relief for parties not involved in the lawsuit before the court. For example, two federal judges prevented Trump from limiting birthright citizenship for the children of pregnant women who hadn’t sued.

Entities like states or nonprofits challenging the president’s policies may still pursue broad relief through legal avenues such as class-action lawsuits, including for classes that reach across the nation. As Justice Brett Kavanaugh said in his concurring opinion, judges may still be able to issue the “functional equivalent of a universal injunction.”

The key to Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s majority opinion was that courts could block policies insofar as their orders provided “complete relief” to the individuals or organizations suing. For birthright citizenship and other issues, that can be complicated when entities like states are seeking relief. That’s because of how individuals can cross state lines after being in a state where Trump’s order is still in effect.

The decision left open the question of whether the president’s order restricting birthright citizenship accorded with the 14th Amendment of the Constitution. The court said the president’s restrictions would be delayed for 30 days after its decision.

Class-Action Lawsuits

During oral arguments in May, Justice Samuel Alito wondered whether eliminating nationwide injunctions would have any practical impact if judges granted blocks for classes that included people throughout the country. That question has already come up in Maryland, where one of the nationwide injunctions on Trump’s birthright citizenship order originated.

When judges certify or approve a class, they allow plaintiffs to represent large groups of people who may be impacted by a particular policy. In those cases, class certification allows judges to provide relief to affected people not directly before the court.

Hours after the Supreme Court’s decision on June 27, the plaintiffs in the birthright citizenship case filed a request to convert their suit to a class action. They asked the judge to certify a class of individuals that included children who would be precluded from receiving citizenship under the president’s order.

The American Civil Liberties Union and other groups on June 27 filed a similar class lawsuit in the District of New Hampshire on behalf of the proposed class of babies and parents who could be affected by the executive order.

In his concurring opinion, Alito was concerned that courts would use class certification as a “significant loophole” to the court’s decision. Referring to the section of federal law outlining the requirements for class certification, Alito said judges must scrupulously adhere to them.

“Otherwise, the universal injunction will return from the grave under the guise of ‘nationwide class relief,’ and today’s decision will be of little more than minor academic interest,” he said.

By Sam Dorman

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Coldplay Concert Offers Us Garden of Eden Moment

Adultery is still illegal in 10 states. It was illegal in 15 states just 30 years ago. There was a time when adultery was a crime in all 50 states!

Uncle SLIC’s lingering loans

School may be out for the summer, but the Student Loan Industrial Complex (SLIC) chugs along no matter what time of the year it is.

Epstein’s Island

The miscommunication by Trump Admin officials on Epstein rival any of the comedic exchanges between the Skipper and Gilligan, without the laughs.

Why Thinking Americans Are Pissed!

Some people in this country do not think much...

Rise by the Conspiracy Theory, Fall by the Conspiracy Theory

The uproar in the MAGA world over the failure to release the Jeffrey Epstein client list should be a cause for serious concern for President Trump.

Ole Miss Football Player Corey Adams Killed in Tennessee Shooting

Ole Miss freshman football player Corey Adams was killed in a shooting in Tennessee, the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office announced Sunday.

Texas AG Sues Masters Swimming Group That Allowed Transgender Athletes

Texas AG Ken Paxton sued an adult swimming organization after it allowed transgender athletes to compete at a women’s spring meet in San Antonio.

American Express Hits Record Revenue as Card Member Spending Surges

American Express generated record second-quarter revenue amid strong spending by cardholders, the company said in a July 18 statement.

Missing Persons in Texas County Floods Revised to 3 From 160

Texas officials said Saturday that most of the 160 people reported missing in Kerr County have been accounted for, but that three are still missing.

Commerce Secretary Says US Still Eyeing 10 Percent Baseline Tariff

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said the US is still aiming to leave a 10 percent baseline tariff on many smaller countries

Trump Signs Order to Reclassify Noncareer Federal Workers

President Trump signed an EO to create a new classification of noncareer federal workers whose roles are focused on implementing president’s policy agenda.

Trump Pledges to Prevent US Central Bank Digital Currency

CBDC will not be allowed in the Us, President Trump said at a White House event, promising to take legislative action to prevent such a situation.

EPA Slashes 23 Percent of Its Workforce, Eliminating Scientific Research Arm

EPA announced it will cut about 23% of its workforce and eliminate its research and development office as part of the agency’s restructuring effort.
spot_img

Related Articles