The New Supreme Court: Not Conservative, but No Longer Liberal

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Epoch Times Header

Despite the establishment mediaโ€™s fact-free description of the current Supreme Court as โ€œconservative,โ€ it really isnโ€™t. But its decisions during the term just ended show that itโ€™s no longer liberal.

A year agoโ€”on July 4, 2021โ€”The Epoch Times published my column assessing the courtโ€™s performance during the term just ended. I pointed out that its decisions didnโ€™t support the common view that the bench consisted of a 6โ€“3 conservative majority. I noted that although six members of the panel adhered to various mixtures of originalism and respect for precedent, none was a conservative activist in the sense that the other three members (Breyer, Kagan, and Sotomayor) were liberal activists. The courtโ€™s last true conservative activist was James McReynolds, who retired in 1941.

My column showed that the courtโ€™s major pronouncements during the previous term mostly stuck to the pattern created by โ€œprogressiveโ€ majorities from about 1940 to about 1990. That pattern had three components:

  • Liberal activist courts refused to respect limits in the federal governmentโ€™s enumerated powers. They manufactured excuses not to interfere when Congress and the executive branch meddled in all sorts of activities outside their constitutional jurisdiction.
  • While giving the feds free rein, the 20th-century liberal majorities manipulated the 14th Amendment to void state laws they didnโ€™t like. Liberal jurists invented a series of extra-constitutional โ€œbalancing testsโ€ for this purpose.
  • They also attacked traditional culture and promoted dependency. They ordered states to grant financial benefits to people who hadnโ€™t earned them. They forced states to shift to a nearly hostile stance toward religion. They voided or rewrote long-standing policies on land use, domestic relations, pornography, abortion, legislative apportionment, and criminal law. They even helped break down traditional rules of sexual behavior. They invented balancing tests to promote these purposes as well.

After surveying the cases last year, I concluded, โ€œAll three [liberal] patterns appear in the constitutional cases decided this term. Indeed, the Roberts court is proving to be more โ€˜progressiveโ€™ than the Rehnquist court of the 1990s and early 2000s.โ€

By Rob Natelson

Read Full Article on TheEpochTimes.com

The Epoch Times
The Epoch Timeshttps://www.theepochtimes.com/
Tired of biased news? The Epoch Times is truthful, factual news that other media outlets don't report. No spin. No agenda. Just honest journalism like it used to be.

Why the Trump Administration is Sitting on the Epstein Files

President Trump, AG Bondi, and FBI Dir. Patel have the advantage over us in that they see the big overall picture when it comes to the Epstein List.

Trumpโ€™s โ€œMajor Statementโ€ On Russia Is A Clumsy Attempt To Thread The Needle

The โ€œmajor statementโ€ on Russia Trump hyped up turned out to be an attempt to thread the needle between escalating US involvement in Ukrainian and walking away from it.

AI Takes Customer Service from Doublespeak to Triplespeak

Corporations are replacing customer service agents with AI agents. Here's a real-life example of attempting to use AI to have my internet restored.

The Left’s Descent into Extremismย ย 

The political left, from mainstream Dems to radical Antifa, have embraced extremism, alienating swaths of the public and undermining their own influence.

Roger Stone Speaks About Trump at Turning Point USA

Longtime Donald Trump friend, Roger Stone, gave a speech at the 2025 TPUSA convention offering his take on the recent Epstein List controversy.

Border Czar Says Physical Appearance โ€˜Canโ€™t Be the Sole Reasonโ€™ to Detain Someone

Border czar Homan said comments were โ€œtaken out of contextโ€ and federal immigration enforcement agents can't detain people based on physical appearances alone.

Capacity of US Coal-Fired Power Plants to Fall Over 15 Percent by 2028

Total operating capacity of coal-fired power plants in US is set to drop to 145 GW by end of 2028, a 15% decline from the 172 GW in operation as of May.

Violence Against ICE Escalates Across America

ICE officers face increased confrontation on the street, which crosses the line between free speech and physical violence.

International Buyers Purchased $56 Billion Worth of US Homes in 1 Year

Foreign buyers purchased $56 billion worth of existing homes in the US between April 2024 and March 2025, up by 33.2% from the previous 12 months.

Trump to Announce $70 Billion Energy and Innovation Investment in Pittsburgh

President Trump is meeting with business leaders to discuss how best to meet the energy and computing needs of the future.

Attorney General Pam Bondi Dismisses Justice Departmentโ€™s Top Ethics Lawyer

AG Pam Bondi terminated the head of the DOJโ€™s ethics division, according to a letter posted to social media by the fired official.

Trumpโ€™s Potential Secondary Tariffs on Russia Would Clobber China, India

President Trump said he will impose โ€œvery severeโ€ secondary tariffs on Russia if President Putin does not agree to a cease-fire with Ukraine in 50 days. (09-14-22)

Trump Says He Spoke to Bongino Amid Reports of Infighting Over Epstein Files

President Trump spoke to FBI Deputy Dir. Dan Bongino, indicating the two remain close despite reported friction over release of Jeffrey Epstein docs.
spot_img

Related Articles