Why we’re still arguing about hydroxychloroquine

Contact Your Elected Officials

The battle over hydroxychloroquine began as a kind of trivial but apparently earnest and hopeful celebrity endorsement of the drug (the celebrity being President Trump). It has devolved into a real political and public-discourse horror show.

Perpetual back-and-forths between those prominent doctors who do not believe in the drugโ€™s effectiveness โ€” coronavirus task force members Anthony Fauci and Brett Giroir are two โ€” and dissident, lesser-known doctors, such as Harvey Risch of Yale University, have given birth to serious questions about how truly scientific the whole conversation has been.

Can hydroxychloroquine be used effectively to treat COVID-19? The most prominent voices say no, citing several randomized controlled trials, but others say it is, citing their own clinical evidence.

The question that nobody seems to be asking is, what is the standard of evidence required for granting emergency use authorizations, or EUAs, for drugs in the first place? And what are the limits of various kinds of clinical trials?

The Food and Drug Administration approved an EUA for use of hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine in hospitalized patients on March 28. Importantly, for the purpose of reinforcing distinct categories, its authorization was for a targeted use: hospitalized patients. When the FDA authorized the drug, there was no significant evidence of effectiveness from randomized controlled trials, or RCTs.

In a March 28 letter on authorization, FDA Chief Scientist Denise Hinton wrote, โ€œBased upon limited in-vitro and anecdotal clinical data in case series, chloroquine phosphate and hydroxychloroquine sulfate are currently recommended for treatment of hospitalized COVID-19 patients in several countries โ€ฆ FDA is issuing this EUA to facilitate the availability of chloroquine phosphate and hydroxychloroquine sulfate during the COVID-19 pandemic to treat patients for whom a clinical trial is not available, or participation is not feasible.โ€

The letter suggests that randomized controlled trials are not the โ€œgold standardโ€ for authorizing an EUA. If they were, the March 28 EUA would not have gone through. RCTs do not appear to be the gold standard in other circumstances of drug approval, either. On July 31, the FDA granted accelerated approval of a cancer medication absent any randomized controlled trial.

Moreover, once the treatments and the trials began, researchers in the most notable studies followed those who the EUA had authorized for treatment, namely hospitalized patients. The FDA has since revoked its authorization of hydroxychloroquine on the basis of those various trials, determining no real effectiveness and even suggesting it is considerably dangerous.

These contextual points, along with a score of clinical evidence, are among the reasons that Risch, a professor of epidemiology at Yale School of Public Health, has argued in favor of using hydroxychloroquine to treat high-risk outpatients early in their disease.

To the evidence, Risch argues that doctors have offered more than enough evidence of hydroxychloroquineโ€™s effectiveness for outpatient use in high-risk patients. To the authorization, the FDA does not need randomized controlled trials to issue an emergency use authorization. It could do so for outpatient use of hydroxychloroquine, and Risch says the evidence is there.

โ€œWeโ€™ve been saying that the people to look at are the ones you have to treat,โ€ Risch said in an interview with the Washington Examiner. โ€œWeโ€™re talking about outpatient, high-risk treatment, and thatโ€™s it.โ€

Risch has emerged as a loud voice in favor of using the drug specifically for that category of patients, so loud and contrarian, in fact, that 25 fellow faculty signed on to a stinging rebuke of his advocacy for a targeted use of the drug.

Risch cites the clinical findings of doctors such as Vladimir Zelenko, a New York physician who has demonstrated success in treating high-risk outpatients with hydroxychloroquine, zinc, and azithromycin. He cites other evidence showing success in high-risk outpatients in Brazil and France, including reduced risk of hospitalization. Risch discusses these studies in a recent Newsweek op-ed (See PDF Below) and in a paper he wrote for the American Journal of Epidemiology (See PDF Below).

These findings, he argues, demonstrate evidence even stronger than a โ€œmay be effectiveโ€ standard, justifying an EUA for outpatient use. โ€œThe FDA canโ€™t go up to a doctor and say, โ€˜You havenโ€™t seen what youโ€™ve seen,โ€™โ€ he said.

by Jeremy Beaman, Commentary Fellow

Read Original Article on Washington Examiner

The Key to Defeating COVID-19 Already Exists. We Need to Start Using It

The-Key-to-Defeating-COVID

Opinion: Early Outpatient Treatment of Symptomatic, High-Risk Covid-19 Patients that Should be Ramped-Up Immediately as Key to the Pandemic Crisis

Early-Outpatient-Treatment-of-Symptomatic-High-Risk-Covid-19-Patients

COVID-19 Treatment – Global HCQ/CQ Studies https://c19study.com/

c19study01-27-2021

The Thinking Conservative
The Thinking Conservativehttps://www.thethinkingconservative.com/
The goal of THE THINKING CONSERVATIVE is to help us educate ourselves on conservative topics of importance to our freedom and our pursuit of happiness. We do this by sharing conservative opinions on all kinds of subjects, from all types of people, and all kinds of media, in a way that will challenge our perceptions and help us to make educated choices.

MyPillowโ€™s CEO Mike Lindell Wins 2 Court Cases

A federal court tossed the $5M ruling against Mike Lindell, saying arbitrators rewrote the rules of his 2021 Cyber Symposium challenge.

Whatโ€™s The Most Realistic Scenario In Which The West Might Replace Zelensky?

Yermak and Budanov agreed with the Anglo-American Axisโ€™ proposal to replace Zelensky with Zaluzhny and โ€œresetโ€ Ukraineโ€™s ties with the West.

Earned vs. Owed

Not since the Donner Party has a group of people so badly misinterpreted the circumstances of their situation like the players of the WNBA.

Just How American are Americaโ€™s Elite Schools?

Their exteriors may be ivy clad, but that faรงade on Americaโ€™s elite universities cloaks secrecy, power politics and globalist attitudes as well.

Multiple Democrats Playing Defense

There is a news situation going on that is...

NASA, SpaceX Launch Crew-11 to Space Station

SpaceXโ€™s Falcon 9 rocket took off on Aug. 1, as the 11th act of the NASA commercial crew program set off for the International Space Station.

US Economy Adds 73,000 New Jobs in July, Fewer Than Market Estimates

U.S. economy added smaller-than-expected number of new jobs last month as labor market cools. Fed. govt. jobs fell by 12,000 and, down by 84,000 this year.

Declassified Durham Report Annex Sheds New Light on Origins of Russia Probe: Grassley

Sen. Grassley released declassified annex to John Durhamโ€™s 2023 report into FBIโ€™s investigation into allegations of Trump campaignโ€“Russia ties.

Appeals Court Hears Arguments Over Whether to Block Trumpโ€™s Tariffs

Multiple judges on an appeals court questioned whether a decades-old law Trump invoked had provided him the authority on tariffs he said it did.

Bessent Says Trump Accounts for Kids Are Backdoor โ€˜For Privatizing Social Securityโ€™

Treasury Sec Scott Bessent said Trump Accounts are โ€œa back door for privatizing Social Security,โ€ but the admin is committed to protecting Social Security.

Trump Says Canadaโ€™s Backing of Palestinian Statehood Threatens US Trade Deal

President Trump said it would be โ€œvery hardโ€ to reach a trade agreement with Canada after PM Carney announced plans to recognize a Palestinian state.

Trump Imposes 25 Percent Tariff on India Plus Unspecified Penalty

Trump said US to impose a 25% tariff on Indian goods and unspecified penalties, citing India's high trade barriers and reliance on Russian energy and arms.

White House Launches Health Information Sharing Initiative

Making Health Technology Great Again centers on giving patients full access to their own health records and making the data useful for both doctors and patients in managing disease.
spot_img

Related Articles