Bannon can see Justice Dept. policies on prosecuting former White House aides for contempt of Congress, judge rules

Contact Your Elected Officials
The Washington Post Header

Former Trump aide hopes to toss indictment for failing to appear before House Jan. 6 panel, citing DOJ policy on White House immunity.

A federal judge, after a Wednesday hearing in the case of Stephen K. Bannon, ordered the Justice Department to turn over to the former White House adviser any writings reflecting its official position on prosecuting current or former U.S. officials claiming immunity from congressional subpoena on grounds of executive privilege.The decision handed an initial victory to the onetime adviser to President Donald Trump. Bannon has suggested that he was relying on the Justice Departmentโ€™s own past advice to White House aides as he fights criminal charges for failing to appear before the House committee investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol attack.

Bannon, who has pleaded not guilty to two counts of contempt of Congress, has argued that he refused to respond to a Sept. 23 subpoena by the committee for testimony and documents on the advice of his counsel, Robert J. Costello, who said that Trump asserted executive privilege over appearances by his former aides. U.S. District Judge Carl J. Nichols of Washington ordered both sides to brief him further in coming weeks on whether Bannonโ€™s claims of immunity would sidestep binding federal appeals court precedent that says defendants cannot invoke their lawyerโ€™s advice as a reason to ignore a lawful congressional subpoena.

โ€œIsnโ€™t there something anomalous, and Iโ€™m not sure what the legal hook for it is, for the Department of Justice to say someone has absolute immunity โ€ฆ and we will not prosecute them, and then to say those statements of [DOJ] official policy are irrelevant in such a prosecution?โ€ Nichols asked.

U.S. prosecutors opposed requests by Bannonโ€™s defense to โ€œgo rummaging around the governmentโ€™s filesโ€ to probe its investigative and prosecutorial decision-making. They called it irrelevant to the elements of Bannonโ€™s case: whether he knew he had been summoned and willfully failed to show up.

โ€œThe summoned witness doesnโ€™t get to decide if Congress can make them show up,โ€ Assistant U.S. Attorney Amanda R. Vaughn argued.

The Justice Department โ€œis making decisions all the time about what it believes merits prosecution and what does not. โ€ฆ Facts could change, circumstances change, itโ€™s just the departmentโ€™s view on whether prosecution is appropriate,โ€ Vaughn argued in court.

Bannon defense attorney David I. Schoen said that witnesses might have to appear before Congress to invoke claims such as the right against self-incrimination, but โ€œexecutive privilege is different,โ€ because the privilege is held not by a witness, but by the president.

Finding otherwise โ€œwould be giving Congress a veto over what executive privilege is,โ€ shifting the balance of powers between a president and lawmakers, Schoen said.

Arguing in court, Costello called the actions an โ€œoutrageousโ€ breach of attorney-client privilege, a bedrock principle of U.S. legal practice that says a lawyer must keep confidential what they are told by their clients.

Nichols noted the government has agreed to turn over an application to a federal judge stating its reasons for seeking records from a Google account in the case โ€” albeit for the wrong Robert Costello. Nichols also ordered prosecutors to turn over for his private review the basis for their seeking subscriber information of Yahoo, Comcast, and Google accounts and data related to a Westchester County, N.Y., phone number.

But Nichols denied Bannonโ€™s demands to see how prosecutors instructed a grand jury that obtained Costelloโ€™s records, citing grand jury secrecy and Bannonโ€™s failure to posit any relevance to his defense. None of the governmentโ€™s requests sought the content of communications, but rather metadata information such the sender, recipient, time and length of communication.

Prosecutors say that because they neither sought the contents of communications nor asked for records directly from Bannonโ€™s attorney or law firm, they did not obtain any confidential communications or protected attorney work product. They said the government has turned over โ€œall discoverable materialโ€ in its control related to Bannonโ€™s attorneys in his case, and would continue to do so if it received more.

Bannon called the governmentโ€™s explanations for investigating Costello โ€” that he was a potential witness to his clientโ€™s actions and that they wanted to corroborate that he told his client of the House subpoena โ€” disingenuous. Bannonโ€™s attorneys urged the judge to reprimand prosecutors for attempting to โ€œdrive a wedgeโ€ between attorney and client.

โ€œI think that message has to be sent,โ€ Schoen said.

โ€œIf you allow this [U.S. attorneyโ€™s] office to do what it did to me to every lawyer in the system, no lawyer is ever going to accept service of processโ€ of a subpoena, Costello added.

Costello noted that evidence it turned over to Bannon included a 14-page FBI summary of two interviews Costello gave prosecutors and FBI agents in his case on Nov. 3 and 8, days before Bannon was indicted. Costello said that in fact, he initiated those videoconference meetings with prosecutors to make the case why they should not charge Bannon.

โ€œI certainly was not advised this was going to be an FBI interview. I would have been out of my mind to do that,โ€ Costello told the court. He added that when his client saw the FBI report, โ€œMr. Bannon was irritated about that, because he thought I had given an interview to the FBI.โ€

By Spencer Hsu

Read Original Article on WashingtonPost.com

The Washington Post
The Washington Posthttps://www.washingtonpost.com/
The Washington Post offers breaking news, live coverage, investigations, analysis, video, photos and opinions with the latest on U.S. and international news.

The Sacred Honor of the 56

Today we're celebrating the sacred honor of the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence.

Alligator Alcatraz: A Bold Step Toward Secure Borders

Alligator Alcatraz funded through FEMA, represents a decisive move by the Trump admin to address illegal immigration with efficiency and resolve.

Is America Broke?

Silicon Valley investor and economic commentator Balaji Srinivasan made...

Hungary: Prideโ„ข Cometh Before the Color Revolution

The EU engaged in a diplomatic siege of the Eastern European nation-state of Hungary pressuring it into embrace global trannyism or face wrath of Brussels.

Understanding the Trump/Musk Feud

The passion Trump and Musk exhibit over the OBBB is not contrived or for show. Each is addressing the problem from completely different approaches.

New White House Faith Office Aims to Ensure US Is Beacon of Freedom for Others

The White House Faith Office wants to see the United States as the leader in advancing religious freedom, its faith director Jennifer Korn said.

Federal Reserve Rates Are Too High, Says Former World Bank Chief

Rates should be between 0.25 and 1.75 percent rather...

Newly Naturalized Citizens Say What American Freedom Means to Them

Nearly 820,000 people pledged allegiance to the United States and became naturalized citizens in 2024.

Noem Waives Environmental Restrictions to Fast-Track Water Barriers in Rio Grande

DHS Sec Kristi Noem waived federal environmental laws to fast-track construction of 17 miles of waterborne barriers in the Rio Grande in South Texas.

US Keeps Pressure on Chinese Goods Amid Vietnam Trade Deal

Transshippingโ€”rerouting goods through a third country to disguise the origin of the productsโ€”is a focal point of trade negotiations with Asian markets.

White House Report Reveals Top Earners, Staffers Working for No Salary

The Trump admin released its yearly report that shows the salaries for White House staffers, also revealing officials who arenโ€™t accepting salaries at all.

Transportation Secretary Urges Governors to Remove Political Messages From Crosswalks, Intersections

Duffy sent letters to governors, mayor of D.C., and gov of Puerto Rico urging them to remove political messaging from intersections and crosswalks.

Bessent: US, India Near Agreement to Lower Tariffs

The United States and India are โ€œvery closeโ€ to a trade agreement, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Tuesday.
spot_img

Related Articles